From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
eHealth (also written
e-health) is a relatively recent healthcare practice supported by electronic processes and communication, dating back to at least 1999. Usage of the term varies. A study in 2005 found 51 unique definitions. Some argue that it is interchangeable with
health informatics with a broad definition covering electronic/digital processes in health while others use it in the narrower sense of healthcare practice using the
Internet. It can also include health applications and links on mobile phones, referred to as
mHealth or m-Health.
Since about 2011, the increasing recognition of the need for better
cyber-security and regulation may result in the need for these
specialized resources to develop safer eHealth solutions that can
withstand these growing threats.
Types
The term
can encompass a range of services or systems that are at the edge of
medicine/healthcare and information technology, including:
- Electronic health record: enabling the communication of patient data between different healthcare professionals (GPs, specialists etc.);
- Computerized physician order entry: a means of requesting diagnostic tests and treatments electronically and receiving the results
- ePrescribing:
access to prescribing options, printing prescriptions to patients and
sometimes electronic transmission of prescriptions from doctors to
pharmacists
- Clinical decision support system:
providing information electronically about protocols and standards for
healthcare professionals to use in diagnosing and treating patients[8]
- Telemedicine: physical and psychological diagnosis and treatments at a distance, including telemonitoring of patients functions;
- Consumer health informatics: use of electronic resources on medical topics by healthy individuals or patients;
- Health knowledge management: e.g.
in an overview of latest medical journals, best practice guidelines or
epidemiological tracking (examples include physician resources such as Medscape and MDLinx);
- Virtual healthcare teams: consisting of healthcare professionals who
collaborate and share information on patients through digital equipment
(for transmural care);
- mHealth or m-Health: includes the use of mobile devices in collecting aggregate and patient-level health data,
providing healthcare information to practitioners, researchers, and
patients, real-time monitoring of patient vitals, and direct provision
of care (via mobile telemedicine);
- Medical research using grids: powerful computing and data management capabilities to handle large amounts of heterogeneous data.[9]
- Health informatics / healthcare information systems:
also often refer to software solutions for appointment scheduling,
patient data management, work schedule management and other
administrative tasks surrounding health
Contested definition
Several
authors have noted the variable usage in the term, from being specific
to the use of the Internet in healthcare to being generally around any
use of computers in healthcare.
[10]
Various authors have considered the evolution of the term and its usage
and how this maps to changes in health informatics and healthcare
generally.
[1][11][12] Oh
et al.,
in a 2005 systematic review of the term's usage, offered the definition
of eHealth as a set of technological themes in health today, more
specifically based on commerce, activities, stakeholders, outcomes,
locations, or perspectives.
[2]
One thing that all sources seem to agree on is that e-Health
initiatives do not originate with the patient, though the patient may be
a member of a patient organization that seeks to do this, as in the
e-Patient movement.
eHealth literacy
eHealth
literacy is defined as “the ability to seek, find, understand and
appraise health information from electronic sources and apply knowledge
gained to addressing or solving a health problem.
[13][14]
According to this definition, eHealth literacy encompasses six types of
literacy: traditional (literacy and numeracy), information, media,
health, computer, and scientific. Of these, media and computer
literacies are unique to the Internet context, with eHealth media
literacy being the awareness of media bias or perspective, the ability
to discern both explicit and implicit meaning from media messages, and
to derive meaning from media messages. The literature includes other
definitions of perceived media capability or efficacy, but these were
not specific to health information on the Internet.
[15]
Having the composite skills of eHealth literacy allows health consumers
to achieve positive outcomes from using the Internet for health
purposes. eHealth literacy has the potential to both protect consumers
from harm and empower them to fully participate in informed
health-related decision making.
[14]
People with high levels of eHealth literacy are also more aware of the
risk of encountering unreliable information on the Internet
[16]
On the other hand, the extension of digital resources to the health
domain in the form of eHealth literacy can also create new gaps between
health consumers.
[15] eHealth literacy hinges not on the mere access to technology, but rather on the skill to apply the accessed knowledge.
[13]
Data exchange
One
of the factors blocking the use of e-Health tools from widespread
acceptance is the concern about privacy issues regarding patient
records, most specifically the EPR (
Electronic patient record).
This main concern has to do with the confidentiality of the data. There
is also concern about non-confidential data however. Each medical
practise has its own jargon and diagnostic tools. To standardize the
exchange of information, various coding schemes may be used in
combination with international medical standards. Systems that deal with
these transfers are often referred to as Health Information Exchange
(HIE). Of the forms of e-Health already mentioned, there are roughly two
types; front-end data exchange and back-end exchange.
Front-end exchange typically involves the patient, while back-end
exchange does not. A common example of a rather simple front-end
exchange is a patient sending a photo taken by mobile phone of a healing
wound and sending it by email to the family doctor for control. Such an
actions may avoid the cost of an expensive visit to the hospital.
A common example of a back-end exchange is when a patient on
vacation visits a doctor who then may request access to the patient's
health records, such as medicine prescriptions, x-ray photographs, or
blood test results. Such an action may reveal allergies or other prior
conditions that are relevant to the visit.
Thesaurus
Successful e-Health initiatives such as
e-Diabetes
have shown that for data exchange to be facilitated either at the
front-end or the back-end, a common thesaurus is needed for terms of
reference.
[7][17] Various medical practises in chronic patient care (such as for
diabetic
patients) already have a well defined set of terms and actions, which
makes standard communication exchange easier, whether the exchange is
initiated by the patient or the caregiver.
In general, explanatory diagnostic information (such as the standard
ICD-10)
may be exchanged insecurely, and private information (such as personal
information from the patient) must be secured. E-health manages both
flows of information, while ensuring the quality of the data exchange.
Early adopters
Patients
living with long term conditions (also called Chronic conditions) over
time often acquire a high level of knowledge about the processes
involved in their own care, and often develop a routine in coping with
their condition. For these types of routine patients, front-end e-Health
solutions tend to be relatively easy to implement.
E-mental health
E-mental health is frequently used to refer to internet based interventions and support for
mental health conditions.
[18]
However, it can also refer to the use of information and communication
technologies that also includes the use of social media, landline and
mobile phones.
[19]
E-mental health services can include information; peer support
services, computer and internet based programs, virtual applications and
games as well as real time interaction with trained clinicians.
[20] Programs can also be delivered using telephones and interactive voice response (IVR).
[21]
Mental disorders includes a range of conditions such as alcohol and drug use disorders,
mood disorders such as depression,
dementia and
Alzheimer's disease, delusional disorders such as
schizophrenia and
anxiety disorders.
[22][page needed] The majority of e-mental health interventions have focused on the treatment of depression and anxiety.
[20] There are, however, programs also for problems as diverse as
smoking cessation,
[23][needs update] gambling,
[24] and post-disaster mental health.
[25]
Advantages and disadvantages
E-mental health has a number of advantages such as being low cost, easily accessible and providing anonymity to users.
[26]
However, there are also a number of disadvantages such as concerns
regarding treatment credibility, user privacy and confidentiality.
[27]
Online security involves the implementation of appropriate safeguards
to protect user privacy and confidentiality. This includes appropriate
collection and handling of user data, the protection of data from
unauthorized access and modification and the safe storage of data.
[28]
E-mental health has been gaining momentum in the academic research as well as practical arenas
[29]
in a wide variety of disciplines such as psychology, clinical social
work, family and marriage therapy, and mental health counseling.
Testifying to this momentum, the E-Mental Health movement has its own
international organization, the International Society for Mental Health
Online.
[30]
Programs
There are at least five programs currently available to treat
anxiety and
depression. Several programs have been identified by the UK
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence as cost effective for use in primary care.
[21] These include
Fearfighter,
[31] a text based
cognitive behavioral therapy program to treat people with phobias, and
Beating the Blues,
[32]
an interactive text, cartoon and video CBT program for anxiety and
depression. Two programs have been supported for use in primary care by
the
Australian Government.
[citation needed] The first is
Anxiety Online,
[33] a text based program for the anxiety, depressive and eating disorders, and the second is
THIS WAY UP,
[34] a set of interactive text, cartoon and video programs for the anxiety and depressive disorders. Another is
iFightDepression®[35]
a multilingual, free to use, web-based tool for self-management of less
severe forms of depression, for use under guidance of a GP or
psychotherapist.
There are a number of online programs relating to
smoking cessation.
QuitCoach[36]
is a personalised quit plan based on the users response to questions
regarding giving up smoking and tailored individually each time the user
logs into the site.
Freedom From Smoking[37]
takes users through lessons that are grouped into modules that provide
information and assignments to complete. The modules guide participants
through steps such as preparing to quit smoking, stopping smoking and
preventing relapse.
Other internet programs have been developed specifically as part
of research into treatment for specific disorders. For example, an
online self-directed therapy for
problem gambling was developed to specifically test this as a method of treatment.
[24]
All participants were given access to a website. The treatment group
was provided with behavioural and cognitive strategies to reduce or quit
gambling. This was presented in the form of a workbook which encouraged
participants to self-monitor their gambling by maintaining an online
log of gambling and gambling urges. Participants could also use a
smartphone application to collect self-monitoring information. Finally
participants could also choose to receive motivational email or text
reminders of their progress and goals.
An internet based intervention was also developed for use after
Hurricane Ike in 2009.
[25]
During this study, 1,249 disaster-affected adults were randomly
recruited to take part in the intervention. Participants were given a
structured interview then invited to access the web intervention using a
unique password. Access to the website was provided for a four-month
period. As participants accessed the site they were randomly assigned to
either the intervention. those assigned to the intervention were
provided with modules consisting of information regarding effective
coping strategies to manage mental health and health risk behaviour.
Cybermedicine
Cybermedicine is the use of the
Internet to deliver
medical services, such as
medical consultations and
drug prescriptions. It is the successor to
telemedicine, wherein
doctors would consult and treat
patients remotely via
telephone or
fax.
Cybermedicine is already being used in small projects where images are transmitted from a
primary care setting to a
medical specialist,
who comments on the case and suggests which intervention might benefit
the patient. A field that lends itself to this approach is
dermatology, where images of an eruption are communicated to a hospital specialist who determines if referral is necessary.
The field has also expanded to include online "ask the doctor"
services that allow patients direct, paid access to consultations (with
varying degrees of depth) with medical professionals (examples include
Bundoo.com,
Doctor Spring,
Teladoc, and
Ask The Doctor).
A Cyber
Doctor,
[38] known in the UK as a Cyber
Physician,
[39] is a medical
professional who does
consultation
via the internet, treating virtual patients, who may never meet face to
face. This is a new area of medicine which has been utilized by the
armed forces and teaching
hospitals offering
online
consultation to patients before making their decision to travel for
unique medical treatment only offered at a particular medical facility.
[38]
Self-monitoring healthcare devices
Self-monitoring
is the use of sensors or tools which are readily available to the
general public to track and record personal data. The sensors are
usually wearable devices and the tools are digitally available through
mobile device applications.
Self-monitoring devices were created for the purpose of allowing
personal data to be instantly available to the individual to be
analyzed. As of now, fitness and health monitoring are the most popular
applications for self-monitoring devices.
[40]
The biggest benefit to self-monitoring devices is the elimination of
the necessity for third party hospitals to run tests, which are both
expensive and lengthy. These devices are an important advancement in the
field of personal health management.
Self-monitoring healthcare devices exist in many forms. An example is the
Nike+ FuelBand, which is a modified version of the original
pedometer.
[40]
This device is wearable on the wrist and allows one to set a personal
goal for a daily energy burn. It records the calories burned and the
number of steps taken for each day while simultaneously functioning as a
watch. To add to the ease of the user interface, it includes both
numeric and visual indicators of whether or not the individual has
achieved his or her daily goal. Finally, it is also synced to an
iPhone app which allows for tracking and sharing of personal record and achievements.
Other monitoring devices have more medical relevance. A well-known device of this type is the
blood glucose monitor.
The use of this device is restricted to diabetic patients and allows
users to measure the blood glucose levels in their body. It is extremely
quantitative and the results are available instantaneously.
[41] However, this device is not as independent of a self-monitoring device as the Nike+ Fuelband because it requires some
patient education
before use. One needs to be able to make connections between the levels
of glucose and the effect of diet and exercise. In addition, the users
must also understand how the treatment should be adjusted based on the
results. In other words, the results are not just static measurements.
The demand for self-monitoring health devices is skyrocketing, as
wireless health technologies have become especially popular in the last
few years. In fact, it is expected that by 2016, self-monitoring health
devices will account for 80% of wireless medical devices.
[42]
The key selling point for these devices is the mobility of information
for consumers. The accessibility of mobile devices such as smartphones
and tablets has increased significantly within the past decade. This has
made it easier for users to access real-time information in a number of
peripheral devices.
There are still many future improvements for self-monitoring
healthcare devices. Although most of these wearable devices have been
excellent at providing direct data to the individual user, the biggest
task which remains at hand is how to effectively use this data. Although
the blood glucose monitor allows the user to take action based on the
results, measurements such as the pulse rate, EKG signals, and calories
do not necessarily serve to actively guide an individual's personal
healthcare management. Consumers are interested in qualitative feedback
in addition to the quantitative measurements recorded by the devices.
[43]
Evaluation
Knowledge
of the socio-economic performance of eHealth is limited, and findings
from evaluations are often challenging to transfer to other settings.
Socio-economic evaluations of some narrow types of mHealth can rely on
health economic methodologies, but larger scale eHealth may have too
many variables, and tortuous, intangible cause and effect links may need
a wider approach.
[44]
In developing countries
eHealth
in general, and telemedicine in particular, is a vital resource to
remote regions of emerging and developing countries but is often
difficult to establish because of the lack of communications
infrastructure.
[45] For example, in Benin, hospitals often can become inaccessible due to flooding during the rainy season
[46]
and across Africa, the low population density, along with severe
weather conditions and the difficult financial situation in many African
states, has meant that the majority of the African people are badly
disadvantaged in medical care. In many regions there is not only a
significant lack of facilities and trained health professionals, but
also no access to eHealth because there is also no internet access in
remote villages, or even a reliable electricity supply.
[47]
Internet connectivity, and the benefits of eHealth, can be brought to these regions using
satellite broadband
technology, and satellite is often the only solution where terrestrial
access may be limited, or poor quality, and one that can provide a fast
connection over a vast coverage area.