Graphene
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Graphene is pure carbon in the form of a very thin, nearly transparent sheet, one atom thick. It is remarkably strong for its very low weight (100 times stronger than steel[1]) and it conducts heat and electricity with great efficiency.[2] While scientists had theorized about graphene for decades, it was first produced in the lab in 2004.[3] Because it is virtually two-dimensional, it interacts oddly with light and with other materials. Researchers have identified the bipolar transistor effect, ballistic transport of charges and large quantum oscillations.
Technically, graphene is a crystalline allotrope of carbon with 2-dimensional properties. In graphene, carbon atoms are densely packed in a regular sp2-bonded atomic-scale chicken wire (hexagonal) pattern. Graphene can be described as a one-atom thick layer of graphite. It is the basic structural element of other allotropes, including graphite, charcoal, carbon nanotubes and fullerenes. It can also be considered as an indefinitely large aromatic molecule, the limiting case of the family of flat polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.
Graphene research has expanded quickly since the substance was first isolated in 2004. Research was informed by theoretical descriptions of graphene's composition, structure and properties, which had all been calculated decades earlier. High-quality graphene also proved to be surprisingly easy to isolate, making more research possible. Andre Geim and Konstantin Novoselov at the University of Manchester won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2010 "for groundbreaking experiments regarding the two-dimensional material graphene".[4]
Definition
"Graphene" is a combination of graphite and the suffix -ene, named by Hanns-Peter Boehm,[5] who described single-layer carbon foils in 1962.[6]The term graphene first appeared in 1987[7] to describe single sheets of graphite as a constituent of graphite intercalation compounds (GICs); conceptually a GIC is a crystalline salt of the intercalant and graphene. The term was also used in early descriptions of carbon nanotubes,[8] as well as for epitaxial graphene[9] and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.[10]
The IUPAC compendium of technology states: "previously, descriptions such as graphite layers, carbon layers, or carbon sheets have been used for the term graphene... it is incorrect to use for a single layer a term which includes the term graphite, which would imply a three-dimensional structure. The term graphene should be used only when the reactions, structural relations or other properties of individual layers are discussed."[11]
Geim defined "isolated or free-standing graphene" as "graphene is a single atomic plane of graphite, which – and this is essential – is sufficiently isolated from its environment to be considered free-standing."[12] This definition is narrower than the IUPAC definition and refers to cleaved, transferred and suspended graphene.[citation needed] Other forms of graphene, such as graphene grown on various metals, can become free-standing if, for example, suspended or transferred to silicon dioxide (SiO
2) or silicon carbide (after its passivation with hydrogen).[13]
Graphene can be considered an "infinite alternant" (only six-member carbon ring) polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH).[14]
Graphene - a low-tech summary
The global market for graphene is reported to have reached $9 million by 2014 with most of these sales being concentrated in the semiconductor, electronics, battery energy and composites. However, the market is set to rapidly grow to ~$100 billion as the material makes further inroads into the silicon market for highly integrated circuits and also in boosting the performance of lithium batteries.[15]Platelets of graphene are also being used in polymers and with carbon fibre to lighten and strengthen those materials and add other properties. This rising demand for graphene means that manufacturers and suppliers are springing up around the world especially in the USA, Europe, India and China.
An exciting new discovery
Although lamellar structures were proposed in thermally reduced graphite oxide as early as 1859 its structure was not determined until 1924. Graphene as term was named by Hanns-Peter Boehm in the 1960s, a combination of graphite and the suffix '-ene', while he was working on single-layer carbon foils. Effectively before 2004 the substance only lived in the laboratory where several spectographers reported seeing thin flakes of graphite that were probably several layers of graphene.Graphene is carbon in a pure form and is extremely strong and appears as a near transparent sheet. It is only one atom thick and it is extremely light. It has great strength which is reported as 100 times the tensile strength of steel. Furthermore carbon is an excellent conductor of electricity, graphene does this very efficiently with electrical current densities 1,000,000 times that of copper. The material has high thermal conductivity too and because it is a two-dimensional material that is almost transparent, it interacts in other interesting and useful ways with light and with other materials.
When graphene was first reliably produced in the lab in 2004 by Andre Geim and Kostya Novoselov at the University of Manchester, single-atom-thick crystallites were extracted from bulk graphite by lifting graphene layers from graphite with adhesive tape then transferred them onto a silicon wafer.
What they had isolated was a new material which is still carbon and it also has the basic structural features of the element that we see in its other allotropes that we have known for centuries, such as in graphite & charcoal and of course more recently carbon nanotubes and fullerenes etc. What was new though is that graphene is 2 dimensional and it therefore has the basic structure of a very large and perhaps infinite aromatic molecule. This structure is bringing new properties that are opening up many new opportunities for the one of the oldest elements known to man. As a result Geim and Novoselov won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2010 for their work in revealing this new two-dimensional material.
Researchers have continued to work on the properties of the material and high-quality graphene has proven to be relatively easy to isolate in ever increasing quantities. This has not only made more research possible but to also allow the properties being discovered to be exploited and practical uses to be developed as confirmed by a flurry of patents.
Properties and Manufacture
Graphene, unlike carbon–nanotubes, has edges that can react chemically. These exposed carbon molecules have special reactivity, as do any imperfections in the graphene sheets. Not surprisingly, because of its 2 dimensional structure and the lateral availability of the carbon, graphene is now known to be the most reactive form of carbon. In addition scientists at Stanford University have reported in 2013 that sheets of graphene one atom thick are a hundred times more chemically reactive than thicker sheets. Consequently controlling the functionalization of graphene sheets will be difficult but may still be the source of even more specialised properties and uses that are still unknown to us today.There are currently several methods to produce graphene described in the scientific and commercial literature showing the intensity of development work globally. One is mechanical cleavage, that is taking layers off multi-layered graphite or by depositing one layer of carbon onto another material. The former is clearly how it was done using adhesive tape, but it is reported that the latter is more capable of making a mono-layer with the fewest defects. Graphene platelets can also be created by chemically cutting open carbon nanotubes, one method describing how the nanotubes are cut open in solution by action of potassium permanganate and sulfuric acid. Chemical, solvent or sonic exfoliation (separation) of graphene layers from graphite has also been developed. Plasma deposition techniques, the reduction of graphene oxides (RGO) and other synthetic methodologies are being introduced as route to scale up manufacture.
Large scale manufacture of graphene is beginning to take place in locations where the chemistry based process industries have the infrastructure needed and can manage the materials, processes and technologies. The processes are moving out of laboratories into locations such as that in North East England where the North East of England Process Industry Cluster already have two commercial manufacturers Applied Graphene Materials[16] & Thomas Swan Limited.[17] The UK Government has also chosen this chemistry based industrial manufacturing cluster to be the base of the UK's National Graphene Applications Centre.[18]
Product Developments Using Graphene
However it is, or may be produced in future, in many cases the graphene needs to be bonded to another material to make it usable. The early researchers used silicon to deposit the material on but developers have moved on to metals such as nickel and copper but also on to more exotic materials such as iridium and ruthenium. Interestingly it has become clear that the atomic structure of the substrate can seed the growth of graphene on the host material. The choice of these hosts should not surprise us as these are materials that are commonly used in the electronics industry and special electronic effects are at the core of the development of the properties graphene. A key product development areas for graphene is aimed at engineering the material in order to build it into semiconductor systems and also figuring out how to develop switching technology. This will then enable the material to be used in several fields of bio-engineering, composite materials, energy technology and nanotechnology. Graphene platelets manufactured by exfoliation or other synthetic routes are being employed in many other areas of product development.Medical Devices
With graphene offering such a large surface area, high electrical conductivity, thinness and strength, it makes for a good candidate material in the development of fast and efficient bio-electric sensory devices. Medial test kits of all kinds and perhaps even embedded chip technology allowing drug levels, glucose, cholesterol and other hormones to be monitored. Functionalised graphene may also be a solution for the treatment of cancer.Graphene is the thinnest material known to science it has been revealed that this nanomaterial is so thin water often doesn’t even know it is present. A study has reported that the extreme thinness of graphene enables it to have near-perfect wetting transparency which is an important property particularly in developing bio-sensor applications.[19] This means that a sensors coated in graphene will have just as much contact with an aqueos system as an uncoated sensor, while at the same time being protected mechanically from its enviroment.
Electronics
High quality graphene has flexibility combined with high tensile strength when combined with being almost completely transparent and conductive. This is a material that will inevitably be used in optoelectronic applications such as LCD touchscreens for smartphones, tablet and desktop computers and televisions.Ultrafiltration
One fascinating reported property of graphene is that it allows water to pass through, while it is almost completely impervious to liquids and gases even small helium molecules. This means that it may be used in ultrafiltration as part of water purification and desalination systems and potentially making biofuel production more efficient.Structural Materials
Graphene being strong, stiff and very light is now being engineered alongside carbon fibre to further strengthen and lighten that material. Thereby bringing the prospect of even lighter yet stronger non-metal structural materials to reduce the weight of automobiles, trains and aircraft and hence reduce the carbon footprint of future transport systems.Photovoltaics
The low levels of light absorbed by graphene may enable it to become a cheaper alternative to silicon in photovoltaic cells. Published research has also shown that when graphene absorbs a photon, it actually generates multiple electrons and that it can work at a wider wavelength range than silicon.This brings the prospect of improving the output from photovoltaic cells allowing their use in even more temperate climates. Graphene’s flexibility could also widening the range of photovoltaic products from which we generate electricity. For example in windows & curtains to power our homes, clothing to power mobile devices and even in transport vehicles.
Storing Electricity
Storing energy in batteries and capacitors is an area of continuous research and development. Lithium ion and polycarbonate chemistry is already allowing us to bring electric vehicles into commercial being. Batteries can hold a lot of energy but take a long time to charge whilst capacitors are conversely speedier to charge with less energy availability. Graphene is predicted to enable the speeding up the charging rates of super-batteries or manufacturing super-capacitors for use in smart phones and portable computing. Meanwhile, graphene enhanced lithium ion batteries will find applications such as electrically powered vehicles (EPV).Wide Ranging Uses
Graphene is already being produced as a powder which can be dispersed in a polymers, adhesive, oil and aqueous and non-aqueous solutions. Such dispersions can be applied to many industries such as advanced composites, batteries/capacitors, barrier materials, coatings, display materials, functional fluids, Films, Inks & Coatings, lubricants, packaging, photovoltaics and thermal devices.History
In 1859 Benjamin Collins Brodie was aware of the highly lamellar structure of thermally reduced graphite oxide.[20]The structure of graphite was solved in 1916[21] by the related method of powder diffraction.[22] It was studied in detail by V. Kohlschütter and P. Haenni in 1918, who also described the properties of graphite oxide paper.[23] Its structure was determined from single-crystal diffraction in 1924.[24]
The theory of graphene was first explored by P. R. Wallace in 1947 as a starting point for understanding the electronic properties of 3D graphite. The emergent massless Dirac equation was first pointed out by Gordon Walter Semenoff and David P. DeVincenzo and Eugene J. Mele.[25] Semenoff emphasized the occurrence in a magnetic field of an electronic Landau level precisely at the Dirac point. This level is responsible for the anomalous integer quantum Hall effect.[26][27][28]
The earliest TEM images of few-layer graphite were published by G. Ruess and F. Vogt in 1948.[29]
Later, single graphene layers were also observed directly by electron microscopy.[30] Before 2004 intercalated graphite compounds were studied under a transmission electron microscope (TEM).
Researchers occasionally observed thin graphitic flakes ("few-layer graphene") and possibly even individual layers. An early, detailed study on few-layer graphite dates to 1962.[31][32]
Starting in the 1970s single layers of graphite were grown epitaxially on top of other materials.[33] This "epitaxial graphene" consists of a single-atom-thick hexagonal lattice of sp2-bonded carbon atoms, as in free-standing graphene. However, there is significant charge transfer from the substrate to the epitaxial graphene, and, in some cases, hybridization between the d-orbitals of the substrate atoms and π orbitals of graphene, which significantly alters the electronic structure of epitaxial graphene.
Single layers of graphite were also observed by transmission electron microscopy within bulk materials, in particular inside soot obtained by chemical exfoliation. Efforts to make thin films of graphite by mechanical exfoliation started in 1990,[34] but nothing thinner than 50 to 100 layers was produced before 2004.
Initial attempts to make atomically thin graphitic films employed exfoliation techniques similar to the drawing method. Multilayer samples down to 10 nm in thickness were obtained.[35] Old papers were unearthed[31] in which researchers tried to isolate graphene starting with intercalated compounds.
These papers reported the observation of very thin graphitic fragments (possibly monolayers) by transmission electron microscopy. Neither of the earlier observations was sufficient to "spark the graphene gold rush", which awaited macroscopic samples of extracted atomic planes.
One of the very first patents pertaining to the production of graphene was filed in October 2002 (US Pat. 7071258).[36] Titled, "Nano-scaled Graphene Plates", this patent detailed one of the very first large scale graphene production processes. Two years later, in 2004 Andre Geim and Kostya Novoselov at University of Manchester extracted single-atom-thick crystallites from bulk graphite.[37] They pulled graphene layers from graphite and transferred them onto thin SiO
2 on a silicon wafer in a process called either micromechanical cleavage or the Scotch tape technique. The SiO
2 electrically isolated the graphene and weakly interacted with it, providing nearly charge-neutral graphene layers.
The silicon beneath the SiO
2 could be used as a "back gate" electrode to vary the charge density in the graphene over a wide range. They may not have been the first to use this technique— US 6667100, filed in 2002, describes how to process commercially available flexible expanded graphite to achieve a graphite thickness of 0.01 thousandth of an inch. The key to success was high-throughput visual recognition of graphene on a properly chosen substrate, which provides a small but noticeable optical contrast.
The cleavage technique led directly to the first observation of the anomalous quantum Hall effect in graphene,[26][28] which provided direct evidence of graphene's theoretically predicted Berry's phase of massless Dirac fermions. The effect was reported soon after by Philip Kim and Yuanbo Zhang in 2005. These experiments started after the researchers observed colleagues who were looking for the quantum Hall effect[38] and Dirac fermions[39] in bulk graphite.
Even though graphene on nickel and on silicon carbide have both existed in the laboratory for decades, graphene mechanically exfoliated on SiO
2 provided the first proof of the Dirac fermion nature of electrons.[citation needed]
Geim and Novoselov received several awards for their pioneering research on graphene, notably the 2010 Nobel Prize in Physics.[40]
Properties
Cracking
In 2014, researchers from Rice University and the Georgia Institute of Technology have discovered that although graphene is possibly the strongest material produced today, but it's also as brittle as ordinary ceramic. Graphene cracks like a glass window, unlike steel which has strong crack resistance. Graphene is 10 times more prone to cracking than steel.[41]Structure
Graphene's stability is due to a tightly packed, periodic array of carbon atoms and an sp2 orbital hybridization - a combination of orbitals px and py that constitute the σ-bond. Graphene has three σ-bonds and one π-bond. The final pz electron makes up the π-bond, and is key to the half-filled band that permits free-moving electrons.[42]Graphene sheets in solid form usually show evidence in diffraction for graphite's (002) layering. This is true of some single-walled nanostructures.[43] However, unlayered graphene with only (hk0) rings has been found in the core of presolar graphite onions.[44] TEM studies show faceting at defects in flat graphene sheets[45] and suggest a role for two-dimensional crystallization from a melt.
Graphene can self-repair holes in its sheets, when exposed to molecules containing carbon, such as hydrocarbons. Bombarded with pure carbon atoms, the atoms perfectly align into hexagons, completely filling the holes.[46][47]
The atomic structure of isolated, single-layer graphene was studied by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on sheets of graphene suspended between bars of a metallic grid.[30] Electron diffraction patterns showed the expected honeycomb lattice. Suspended graphene also showed "rippling" of the flat sheet, with amplitude of about one nanometer. These ripples may be intrinsic to the material as a result of the instability of two-dimensional crystals,[35][48][49] or may originate from the ubiquitous dirt seen in all TEM images of graphene. Atomic resolution real-space images of isolated, single-layer graphene on SiO
2 substrates are available[50][51] via scanning tunneling microscopy. Photoresist residue, which must be removed to obtain atomic-resolution images, may be the "adsorbates" observed in TEM images, and may explain the observed rippling. Rippling on SiO
2 is caused by conformation of graphene to the underlying SiO
2, and is not intrinsic.[50]
Chemical
Graphene is the only form of carbon (and generally all solid materials) in which each single atom is in exposure for chemical reaction from two sides (due to the 2D structure). It is known that carbon atoms at the edge of graphene sheets have special chemical reactivity, and graphene has the highest ratio of edgy carbons (in comparison with similar materials such as carbon nanotubes). In addition, various types of defects within the sheet, which are very common, increase the chemical reactivity.[52]The onset temperature of reaction between the basal plane of single-layer graphene and oxygen gas is below 260 °C [53] and the graphene burns at very low temperature (e.g., 350 °C).[54] In fact, graphene is chemically the most reactive form of carbon, owing to the lateral availability of carbon atoms.
Graphene is commonly modified with oxygen- and nitrogen-containing functional groups and analyzed by infrared spectroscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. However, determination of structures of graphene with oxygen-[55] and nitrogen-[56] containing functional groups is a difficult task unless the structures are well controlled.
In 2013, Stanford University physicists reported that sheets of graphene one atom thick are a hundred times more chemically reactive than thicker sheets.[vague][57]
Electronic
Graphene is a semi-metal or zero-gap semiconductor. Four electronic properties separate it from other condensed matter systems.
Electronic spectrum
Electrons propagating through graphene's honeycomb lattice effectively lose their mass, producing quasi-particles that are described by a 2D analogue of the Dirac equation rather than the Schrödinger equation for spin-1⁄2 particles.[58][59]Dispersion relation
Using a conventional tight-binding model the dispersion relation produces energy of the electrons with wave vector k is[60][61]
As a consequence, at low energies, even neglecting the true spin, the electrons can be described by an equation that is formally equivalent to the massless Dirac equation. Hence, the electrons and holes are called Dirac fermions and the six corners are called the Dirac points.[60] This pseudo-relativistic description is restricted to the chiral limit, i.e., to vanishing rest mass M0, which leads to interesting additional features:[60][63]
is the vector of the Pauli matrices, 
is the two-component wave function of the electrons, and E is their energy.[58]The equation describing the electrons' linear dispersion relation is
;where the wavevector k is measured from the Dirac points (the zero of energy is chosen here to coincide with the Dirac points). The equation uses a pseudospin matrix formula that describes two sublattices of the honeycomb lattice.[62]
Single-atom wave propagation
Electron waves in graphene propagate within a single-atom layer, making them sensitive to the proximity of other materials such as high-κ dielectrics, superconductors and ferromagnetics.Electron transport
Experimental results from transport measurements show that graphene has a remarkably high electron mobility at room temperature, with reported values in excess of 15,000 cm2·V−1·s−1.[35] Additionally, the symmetry of the experimentally measured conductance indicates that hole and electron mobilities should be nearly the same.[59] The mobility is nearly independent of temperature between 10 K and 100 K,[26][64][65] which implies that the dominant scattering mechanism is defect scattering. Scattering by the acoustic phonons of graphene intrinsically limits room temperature mobility to 200,000 cm2·V−1·s−1 at a carrier density of 1012 cm−2,[65][66] which was later demonstrated and is greater than copper.[42]The corresponding resistivity of the graphene sheet would be 10−6 Ω·cm. This is less than the resistivity of silver, the lowest known at room temperature.[67] However, for room temperature graphene on SiO
2 substrates, scattering of electrons by optical phonons of the substrate is a larger effect than scattering by graphene’s own phonons. This limits mobility to 40,000 cm2·V−1·s−1.[65]
Electrical resistance in 40-nanometer-wide nanoribbons of epitaxial graphene changes in discrete steps. The ribbons' conductance exceeds predictions by a factor of 10. The ribbons can act more like optical waveguides or quantum dots, allowing electrons to flow smoothly along the ribbon edges. In copper, resistance increases in proportion to length as electrons encounter impurities.[68][69]
Transport is dominated by two modes. One is ballistic and temperature independent, while the other is thermally activated. Ballistic electrons resemble those in cylindrical carbon nanotubes. At room temperature, resistance increases abruptly at a particular length—the ballistic mode at 16 micrometres and the other at 160 nanometres (1% of the former length).[68]
The ribbons were grown on the edges of three-dimensional structures etched into silicon carbide wafers. When the wafers are heated to approximately 1,000 °C (1,830 °F), silicon is preferentially driven off along the edges, forming nanoribbons whose structure is determined by the pattern of the three-dimensional surface. The nanoribbons had perfectly smooth edges, annealed by the fabrication process. Electron mobility measurements surpassing one million correspond to a sheet resistance of one ohm per square— two orders of magnitude lower than in two-dimensional graphene.[68]
Graphene electrons can cover micrometer distances without scattering, even at room temperature.[58]
Despite zero carrier density near the Dirac points, graphene exhibits a minimum conductivity on the order of
. The origin of this minimum conductivity is still unclear. However, rippling of the graphene sheet or ionized impurities in the SiO2 substrate may lead to local puddles of carriers that allow conduction.[59] Several theories suggest that the minimum conductivity should be
; however, most measurements are of order or greater[35] and depend on impurity concentration.[70]Graphene doped with various gaseous species (both acceptors and donors) can be returned to an undoped state by gentle heating in vacuum.[70][71] Even for dopant concentrations in excess of 1012 cm−2 carrier mobility exhibits no observable change.[71] Graphene doped with potassium in ultra-high vacuum at low temperature can reduce mobility 20-fold.[70][72] The mobility reduction is reversible on heating the graphene to remove the potassium.
Due to graphene's two dimensions, charge fractionalization (where the apparent charge of individual pseudoparticles in low-dimensional systems is less than a single quantum[73]) is thought to occur. It may therefore be a suitable material for constructing quantum computers[74] using anyonic circuits.[75]
Anomalous quantum Hall effect
The quantum Hall effect is a quantum mechanical version of the Hall effect, which is the production of transverse (perpendicular to the main current) conductivity in the presence of a magnetic field. The quantization of the Hall effect
at integer multiples (the "Landau level") of the basic quantity 
(where e is the elementary electric charge and h is Planck's constant) It can usually be observed only in very clean silicon or gallium arsenide solids at temperatures around 3 K and very high magnetic fields.Graphene shows the quantum Hall effect with respect to conductivity-quantization: the effect is anomalous in that the sequence of steps is shifted by 1/2 with respect to the standard sequence and with an additional factor of 4. Graphene's Hall conductivity is
, where N is the Landau level and the double valley and double spin degeneracies give the factor of 4.[35] These anomalies are present at room temperature, i.e. at roughly 20 °C.[26]This behavior is a direct result of graphene's massless Dirac electrons. In a magnetic field, their spectrum has a Landau level with energy precisely at the Dirac point. This level is a consequence of the Atiyah–Singer index theorem and is half-filled in neutral graphene,[60] leading to the "+1/2" in the Hall conductivity.[27] Bilayer graphene also shows the quantum Hall effect, but with only one of the two anomalies (i.e.
). In the second anomaly, the first plateau at N=0 is absent, indicating that bilayer graphene stays metallic at the neutrality point.[35]Unlike normal metals, graphene's longitudinal esistance shows maxima rather than minima for integral values of the Landau filling factor in measurements of the Shubnikov–De Haas oscillations, whereby the term integral quantum Hall effect. These oscillations show a phase shift of π, known as Berry’s phase.[26][59] Berry’s phase arises due to the zero effective carrier mass near the Dirac points.[28] The temperature dependence of the oscillations reveals that the carriers have a non-zero cyclotron mass, despite their zero effective mass.[26]
Graphene samples prepared on nickel films, and on both the silicon face and carbon face of silicon carbide, show the anomalous effect directly in electrical measurements.[76][77][78][79][80][81] Graphitic layers on the carbon face of silicon carbide show a clear Dirac spectrum in angle-resolved photoemission experiments, and the effect is observed in cyclotron resonance and tunneling experiments.[82]
Strong magnetic fields
In magnetic fields above 10 Teslas or so additional plateaus of the Hall conductivity at σxy = νe2/h with ν = 0, ±1, ±4 are observed.[83] A plateau at ν = 3[84] and the fractional quantum Hall effect at ν = 1⁄3 were also reported.[84][85]These observations with ν = 0, ±1, ±3, ±4 indicate that the four-fold degeneracy (two valley and two spin degrees of freedom) of the Landau energy levels is partially or completely lifted.
Casimir effect
The Casimir effect is an interaction between disjoint neutral bodies provoked by the fluctuations of the electrodynamical vacuum. Mathematically it can be explained by considering the normal modes of electromagnetic fields, which explicitly depend on the boundary (or matching) conditions on the interacting bodies' surfaces. Since graphene/electromagnetic field interaction is strong for a one-atom-thick material, the Casimir effect is of growing interest.[86][87]van der Waals force
The van der Waals force (or dispersion force) is also unusual, obeying an inverse cubic, asymptotic power law in contrast to the usual inverse quartic.[88]"Massive" electrons
Graphene's unit cell has two identical carbon atoms and two zero-energy states: one in which the electron resides on atom A, the other in which the electron resides on atom B. Both states exist at exactly zero energy. However, if the two atoms in the unit cell are not identical, the situation changes.Hunt et al. show that placing hBN in contact with graphene can alter the potential felt at atom A versus atom B enough that the electrons develop a mass and accompanying band gap of about 30 meV.[89]
The mass can be positive or negative. An arrangement that slightly raises the energy of an electron on atom A relative to atom B gives it a positive mass, while an arrangement that raises the energy of atom B produces a negative electron mass. The two versions behave alike and are indistinguishable via optical spectroscopy. An electron traveling from a positive-mass region to a negative-mass region must cross an intermediate region where its mass once again becomes zero. This region is gapless and therefore metallic. Metallic modes bounding semiconducting regions of opposite-sign mass is a hallmark of a topological phase and display much the same physics as topological insulators.[89]
If the mass in graphene can be controlled, electrons can be confined to massless regions by surrounding them with massive regions, allowing the patterning of quantum dots, wires, and other mesoscopic structures. It also produces one-dimensional conductors along the boundary. These wires would be protected against backscattering and could carry currents without dissipation.[89]
Optical
Graphene's unique optical properties produce an unexpectedly high opacity for an atomic monolayer in vacuum, absorbing πα ≈ 2.3% of white light, where α is the fine-structure constant.[90] This is a consequence of the "unusual low-energy electronic structure of monolayer graphene that features electron and hole conical bands meeting each other at the Dirac point... [which] is qualitatively different from more common quadratic massive bands".[91] Based on the Slonczewski–Weiss–McClure (SWMcC) band model of graphite, the interatomic distance, hopping value and frequency cancel when optical conductance is calculated using Fresnel equations in the thin-film limit.
Although confirmed experimentally, the measurement is not precise enough to improve on other techniques for determining the fine-structure constant.[92]
Graphene's band gap can be tuned from 0 to 0.25 eV (about 5 micrometre wavelength) by applying voltage to a dual-gate bilayer graphene field-effect transistor (FET) at room temperature.[93] The optical response of graphene nanoribbons is tunable into the terahertz regime by an applied magnetic field.[94] Graphene/graphene oxide systems exhibit electrochromic behavior, allowing tuning of both linear and ultrafast optical properties.[95]
A graphene-based Bragg grating (one-dimensional photonic crystal) has been fabricated and demonstrated its capability for excitation of surface electromagnetic waves in the periodic structure by using 633 nm He–Ne laser as the light source.[96]
Saturable absorption
Such unique absorption could become saturated when the input optical intensity is above a threshold value. This nonlinear optical behavior is termed saturable absorption and the threshold value is called the saturation fluence. Graphene can be saturated readily under strong excitation over the visible to near-infrared region, due to the universal optical absorption and zero band gap. This has relevance for the mode locking of fiber lasers, where fullband mode locking has been achieved by graphene-based saturable absorber. Due to this special property, graphene has wide application in ultrafast photonics.Moreover, the optical response of graphene/graphene oxide layers can be tuned electrically.[95][97]
Saturable absorption in graphene could occur at the Microwave and Terahertz band, owing to its wideband optical absorption property. The microwave saturable absorption in graphene demonstrates the possibility of graphene microwave and terahertz photonics devices, such as microwave saturable absorber, modulator, polarizer, microwave signal processing and broad-band wireless access networks.[98]
Nonlinear Kerr effect
Under more intensive laser illumination, graphene could also possess a nonlinear phase shift due to the optical nonlinear Kerr effect. Based on a typical open and close aperture z-scan measurement, graphene possesses a giant non-linear Kerr coefficient of 10−7 cm2·W−1, almost nine orders of magnitude larger than that of bulk dielectrics.[99] This suggests that graphene may be a nonlinear Kerr medium, paving the way for graphene-based nonlinear Kerr photonics such as a soliton.Excitonic
First-principle calculations with quasiparticle corrections and many-body effects are performed to study the electronic and optical properties of graphene-based materials. The approach is described as three stages.[100] With GW calculation, the properties of graphene-based materials are accurately investigated, including graphene,[101] graphene nanoribbons,[102] edge and surface functionalized armchair graphene nanoribbons,[103] hydrogen saturated armchair graphene nanoribbons,[104] Josephson effect in graphene SNS junctions with single localized defect[105] and scaling properties in armchair graphene nanoribbons.[106]Thermal
Graphene is a perfect thermal conductor. Its thermal conductivity was measured recently at room temperature and it is much higher than the value observed in all the other carbon structures as carbon nanotubes, graphite and diamond (> 5000 W·m−1·K−1). The ballistic thermal conductance of graphene is isotropic, i.e. same in all directions. Graphite, the 3 D version of graphene, shows a thermal conductivity about 5 times smaller (1000 W·m−1·K−1). The phenomenon is governed by the presence of elastic waves propagating in the graphene lattice, called phonons. The study of thermal conductivity in graphene may have important implications in graphene-based electronic devices. Even on a substrate, thermal conductivity reaches 600 W·m−1·K−1.[42]Stability
Ab initio calculations show that a graphene sheet is thermodynamically unstable if its size is less than about 20 nm ("graphene is the least stable structure until about 6000 atoms") and becomes the most stable fullerene (as within graphite) only for molecules larger than 24,000 atoms.[107]Conductivity
The near-room temperature thermal conductivity of graphene was measured to be between (4.84±0.44) × 103 to (5.30±0.48) × 103 W·m−1·K−1. These measurements, made by a non-contact optical technique, are in excess of those measured for carbon nanotubes or diamonds. The isotopic composition, the ratio of 12C to 13C, has a significant impact on thermal conductivity, where isotopically pure 12C graphene has higher conductivity than either a 50:50 isotope ratio or the naturally occurring 99:1 ratio.[108] It can be shown by using the Wiedemann–Franz law, that the thermal conduction is phonon-dominated.[109] However, for a gated graphene strip, an applied gate bias causing a Fermi energy shift much larger than kBT can cause the electronic contribution to increase and dominate over the phonon contribution at low temperatures. The ballistic thermal conductance of graphene is isotropic.[110][111]Potential for this high conductivity can be seen by considering graphite, a 3D version of graphene that has basal plane thermal conductivity of over a 1000 W·m−1·K−1 (comparable to diamond). In graphite, the c-axis (out of plane) thermal conductivity is over a factor of ~100 smaller due to the weak binding forces between basal planes as well as the larger lattice spacing.[112] In addition, the ballistic thermal conductance of graphene is shown to give the lower limit of the ballistic thermal conductances, per unit circumference, length of carbon nanotubes.[113]
Despite its 2-D nature, graphene has 3 acoustic phonon modes. The two in-plane modes (LA, TA) have a linear dispersion relation, whereas the out of plane mode (ZA) has a quadratic dispersion relation. Due to this, the T2 dependent thermal conductivity contribution of the linear modes is dominated at low temperatures by the T1.5 contribution of the out of plane mode.[113] Some graphene phonon bands display negative Grüneisen parameters.[114] At low temperatures (where most optical modes with positive Grüneisen parameters are still not excited) the contribution from the negative Grüneisen parameters will be dominant and thermal expansion coefficient (which is directly proportional to Grüneisen parameters) negative. The lowest negative Grüneisen parameters correspond to the lowest transversal acoustic ZA modes. Phonon frequencies for such modes increase with the in-plane lattice parameter since atoms in the layer upon stretching will be less free to move in the z direction. This is similar to the behavior of a string, which, when it is stretched, will have vibrations of smaller amplitude and higher frequency. This phenomenon, named "membrane effect", was predicted by Lifshitz in 1952.[115]
Mechanical
The carbon–carbon bond length in graphene is about 0.142 nanometers.[116] Graphene sheets stack to form graphite with an interplanar spacing of 0.335 nm.Graphene is highly impermeable and is highly elastic.[42]
Graphene is one of the strongest materials known with a breaking strength over 100 times greater than a hypothetical steel film of the same (thin) thickness,[42] with a Young's modulus (stiffness) of 1 TPa (150,000,000 psi).[117] The Nobel announcement illustrated this by saying that a 1 square meter graphene hammock would support a 4 kg cat but would weigh only as much as one of the cat's whiskers, at 0.77 mg (about 0.001% of the weight of 1 m2 of paper).[118]
Flat graphene sheets are unstable with respect to scrolling, i.e. bending into a cylindrical shape, which is its lower-energy state.[119]
The spring constant of suspended graphene sheets has been measured using an atomic force microscope (AFM). Graphene sheets, held together by van der Waals forces, were suspended over SiO
2 cavities where an AFM tip was probed to test its mechanical properties. Its spring constant was in the range 1–5 N/m and the stiffness was 0.5 TPa, which differs from that of bulk graphite. These high values make graphene very strong and rigid. These intrinsic properties could lead to using graphene for NEMS applications such as pressure sensors and resonators.[120]
As is true of all materials, regions of graphene are subject to thermal and quantum fluctuations in relative displacement. Although the amplitude of these fluctuations is bounded in 3D structures (even in the limit of infinite size), the Mermin–Wagner theorem shows that the amplitude of long-wavelength fluctuations grows logarithmically with the scale of a 2D structure, and would therefore be unbounded in structures of infinite size. Local deformation and elastic strain are negligibly affected by this long-range divergence in relative displacement. It is believed that a sufficiently large 2D structure, in the absence of applied lateral tension, will bend and crumple to form a fluctuating 3D structure. Researchers have observed ripples in suspended layers of graphene,[30] and it has been proposed that the ripples are caused by thermal fluctuations in the material. As a consequence of these dynamical deformations, it is debatable whether graphene is truly a 2D structure.[35][48][49][121]
Spin transport
Graphene is claimed to be an ideal material for spintronics due to its small spin-orbit interaction and the near absence of nuclear magnetic moments in carbon (as well as a weak hyperfine interaction). Electrical spin current injection and detection has been demonstrated up to room temperature.[122][123][124] Spin coherence length above 1 micrometre at room temperature was observed,[122] and control of the spin current polarity with an electrical gate was observed at low temperature.[123]Strong magnetic fields
Graphene's quantum Hall effect in magnetic fields above 10 Teslas or so reveals additional interesting features. Additional plateaus of the Hall conductivity at
with 
are observed.[83] Also, the observation of a plateau at 
[84] and the fractional quantum Hall effect at 
were reported.[84][85]These observations with
indicate that the four-fold degeneracy (two valley and two spin degrees of freedom) of the Landau energy levels is partially or completely lifted. One hypothesis is that the magnetic catalysis of symmetry breaking is responsible for lifting the degeneracy.[citation needed]Forms
Nanostripes
Graphene nanoribbons ("nanostripes" in the "zig-zag" orientation), at low temperatures, show spin-polarized metallic edge currents, which also suggests applications in the new field of spintronics. (In the "armchair" orientation, the edges behave like semiconductors.[58])Oxide
Using paper-making techniques on dispersed, oxidized and chemically processed graphite in water, the monolayer flakes form a single sheet and create strong bonds. These sheets, called graphene oxide paper have a measured tensile modulus of 32 GPa.[125] The chemical property of graphite oxide is related to the functional groups attached to graphene sheets. These can change the polymerization pathway and similar chemical processes.[126] Graphene oxide flakes in polymers display enhanced photo-conducting properties.[127] Graphene is normally hydrophobic and impermeable to all gases and liquids (vacuum-tight). However when formed into graphene oxide-based capillary membrane, both liquid water and water vapor flow through as quickly as if the membrane was not present.[128]Chemical modification
Soluble fragments of graphene can be prepared in the laboratory[129] through chemical modification of graphite. First, microcrystalline graphite is treated with an acidic mixture of sulfuric acid and nitric acid. A series of oxidation and exfoliation steps produce small graphene plates with carboxyl groups at their edges. These are converted to acid chloride groups by treatment with thionyl chloride; next, they are converted to the corresponding graphene amide via treatment with octadecylamine. The resulting material (circular graphene layers of 5.3 angstrom thickness) is soluble in tetrahydrofuran, tetrachloromethane and dichloroethane.
Refluxing single-layer graphene oxide (SLGO) in solvents leads to size reduction and folding of individual sheets as well as loss of carboxylic group functionality, by up to 20%, indicating thermal instabilities of SLGO sheets dependent on their preparation methodology. When using thionyl chloride, acyl chloride groups result, which can then form aliphatic and aromatic amides with a reactivity conversion of around 70–80%.
Hydrazine reflux is commonly used for reducing SLGO to SLG(R), but titrations show that only around 20–30% of the carboxylic groups are lost, leaving a significant number available for chemical attachment. Analysis of SLG(R) generated by this route reveals that the system is unstable and using a room temperature stirring with HCl (< 1.0 M) leads to around 60% loss of COOH functionality. Room temperature treatment of SLGO with carbodiimides leads to the collapse of the individual sheets into star-like clusters that exhibited poor subsequent reactivity with amines (ca. 3–5% conversion of the intermediate to the final amide).[130] It is apparent that conventional chemical treatment of carboxylic groups on SLGO generates morphological changes of individual sheets that leads to a reduction in chemical reactivity, which may potentially limit their use in composite synthesis. Therefore, chemical reactions types have been explored. SLGO has also been grafted with polyallylamine, cross-linked through epoxy groups. When filtered into graphene oxide paper, these composites exhibit increased stiffness and strength relative to unmodified graphene oxide paper.[131]
Full hydrogenation from both sides of graphene sheet results in graphane, but partial hydrogenation leads to hydrogenated graphene.[132] Similarly, both-side fluorination of graphene (or chemical and mechanical exfoliation of graphite fluoride) leads to fluorographene (graphene fluoride),[133] while partial fluorination (generally halogenation) provides fluorinated (halogenated) graphene.
Ligand/ Complex
Graphene can be a huge ligand to coordinate metals and metal ions by introducing functional groups. Structures of graphene ligands are similar to e.g. metal-porphyrin complex, metal-phthalocyanine complex, and metal-phenanthroline complex. Copper and nickel ions has been coordinated with graphene ligands.[134][135]Bilayer
Bilayer graphene displays the anomalous quantum Hall effect, a tunable band gap[136] and potential for excitonic condensation[137] –making it a promising candidate for optoelectronic and nanoelectronic applications. Bilayer graphene typically can be found either in twisted configurations where the two layers are rotated relative to each other or graphitic Bernal stacked configurations where half the atoms in one layer lie atop half the atoms in the other. Stacking order and orientation govern the optical and electronic properties of bilayer graphene.One way to synthesize bilayer graphene is via chemical vapor deposition, which can produce large bilayer regions that almost exclusively conform to a Bernal stack geometry.[138]
Fiber
In 2011, Xinming Li and Hongwei Zhu from Tsinghua University reported a novel yet simple approach to fabricate graphene fibers from chemical vapor deposition grown graphene films.[139] The method was scalable and controllable, delivering tunable morphology and pore structure by controlling the evaporation of solvents with suitable surface tension. Flexible all-solid-state supercapacitors based on this graphene fibers were demonstrated in 2013.[140]3D
In 2013, a three-dimensional honeycomb of hexagonally arranged carbon was termed 3D graphene, although self-supporting 3D graphene has not yet been produced.[141]Reinforced
Graphene reinforced with embedded carbon nanotube reinforcing bars (“rebar”) is easier to manipulate, while improving the electrical and mechanical qualities of both materials.[142][143]Functionalized single- or multiwalled carbon nanotubes are spin-coated on copper foils and then heated and cooled, using the nanotubes themselves as the carbon source. Under heating, the functional carbon groups decompose into graphene, while the nanotubes partially split and form in-plane covalent bonds with the graphene, adding strength. π–π stacking domains add more strength.
The nanotubes can overlap, making the material a better conductor than standard CVD-grown graphene. The nanotubes effectively bridge the grain boundaries found in conventional graphene. The technique eliminates the traces of substrate on which later-separated sheets were deposited using epitaxy.[142]
Stacks of a few layers, have been proposed as a cost-effective and physically flexible replacement for indium tin oxide (ITO) used in displays and photovoltaic cells.[142]
Production techniques
Isolated 2D crystals cannot be grown via chemical synthesis beyond small sizes even in principle, because the rapid growth of phonon density with increasing lateral size forces 2D crystallites to bend into the third dimension.[12] However, other routes to 2d materials exist:Fundamental forces place seemingly insurmountable barriers in the way of creating [2D crystals]... The nascent 2D crystallites try to minimize their surface energy and inevitably morph into one of the rich variety of stable 3D structures that occur in soot.The two basic approaches to producing graphene are to cleave multi-layer graphite into single layers or to grow it epitaxially by depositing one layer of carbon onto another material. The former was developed first, using adhesive tape to peel monolayers away. In either case, the graphite must then be bonded to some substrate to retain its 2d shape.[12] Other techniques have also been developed.
But there is a way around the problem. Interactions with 3D structures stabilize 2D crystals during growth. So one can make 2D crystals sandwiched between or placed on top of the atomic planes of a bulk crystal. In that respect, graphene already exists within graphite... One can then hope to fool Nature and extract single-atom-thick crystallites at a low enough temperature that they remain in the quenched state prescribed by the original higher-temperature 3D growth.[144]
Exfoliation
As of 2014 exfoliation produced graphene with the lowest number of defects and highest electron mobility.[42]Adhesive tape
Cleavage is also known as exfoliation. Achieving single layers typically requires multiple exfoliation steps, each producing a slice with fewer layers, until only one remains. Geim and Novosolev used adhesive tape to split their graphene.After exfoliation the flakes are deposited on a silicon wafer using "dry deposition". Crystallites larger than 1 mm and visible to the naked eye can be obtained with the technique. It is often referred to as a "scotch tape" or "drawing" method. The latter name appeared because the dry deposition resembles drawing with a piece of graphite.[144]
Wedge-based mechanical exfoliation
Another controlled technique to produce few layers of graphene uses a wedge type of tool[145] to address difficulties of the adhesive tape method. In this method, a sharp single-crystal diamond wedge penetrates onto the graphite source to exfoliate layers. This method uses highly ordered pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) as the starting material. The experiments were supported by molecular dynamic simulations.[146]Reduction of graphite oxide
Graphite oxide reduction was probably the first method of graphene synthesis. P. Boehm reported producing monolayer flakes of reduced graphene oxide in 1962.[147] Geim acknowledged Boehm's contribution.[148] Rapid heating of graphite oxide and exfoliation yields highly dispersed carbon powder with a few percent of graphene flakes. Reduction of graphite oxide monolayer films, e.g. by hydrazine with annealing in argon/hydrogen, was reported to yield graphene films. However, the quality is lower compared to scotch-tape graphene, due to incomplete removal of functional groups.Furthermore, the oxidation protocol introduces permanent defects due to over-oxidation. The oxidation protocol was enhanced to yield graphene oxide with an almost intact carbon framework that allows efficient removal of functional groups. The measured charge carrier mobility exceeded 1,000 centimetres (393.70 in)/Vs.[149] Spectroscopic analysis of reduced graphene oxide has been conducted.[150][151]
Shearing
In 2014 defect-free, unoxidized graphene-containing liquids were made from graphite using mixers that produce local shear rates greater than 10. Commercial graphene products using the output were announced. The method was claimed to be applicable to boron nitride, Molybdenum disulfied and other layered crystals.[152][153]Sonication
Applying a layer of graphite oxide film to a DVD and burning it in a DVD writer produced a thin graphene film with high electrical conductivity (1738 siemens per meter) and specific surface area (1520 square meters per gram) that was highly resistant and malleable.[154]Solvent-aided
Dispersing graphite in a proper liquid medium can produce graphene by sonication. Graphene is separated from graphite by centrifugation,[155] producing graphene concentrations initially up to 0.01 mg/ml in N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP) and later to 2.1 mg/ml in NMP,.[156] Using a suitable ionic liquid as the dispersing liquid medium produced concentrations of 5.33 mg/ml.[157] Graphene concentration produced by this method is very low, because nothing prevents the sheets from restacking due to van der Waals forces. The maximum concentrations achieved are the points at which the van der Waals forces overcome the interactive forces between the graphene sheets and the solvent molecules.Solvent/surfactant-aided
Adding a surfactant to a solvent prior to sonication prevents restacking by adsorbing to the graphene's surface. This produces a higher graphene concentration, but removing the surfactant requires chemical treatments.[citation needed]Immiscible liquids
Sonicating graphite at the interface of two immiscible liquids, most notably heptane and water, producing macro-scale graphene films. The graphene sheets are adsorbed to the high energy interface between the heptane and the water, where they are kept from restacking. The graphene remains at the interface even when exposed to force in excess of 300,000 g. The solvents may then be evaporated.The sheets are up to ~95% transparent and conductive.[158]
Epitaxy
Epitaxy refers to the deposition of a crystalline overlayer on a crystalline substrate, where there is registry between the two. In some cases epitaxial graphene layers are coupled to surfaces weakly enough (by Van der Waals forces) to retain the two dimensional electronic band structure of isolated graphene.[159][160] An example of weakly coupled epitaxial graphene is the one grown on SiC.[37]Graphene monolayers grown on silicon carbide and iridium are weakly coupled to these substrates (how weakly remains debated) and the graphene–substrate interaction can be further passivated.[13]
Silicon carbide
Heating silicon carbide (SiC) to high temperatures (>1100 °C) under low pressures (~10−6 torr) reduces it to graphene.[161] This process produces epitaxial graphene with dimensions dependent upon the size of the wafer. The face of the SiC used for graphene formation, silicon- or carbon-terminated, highly influences the thickness, mobility and carrier density of the resulting graphene.Graphene's electronic band-structure (so-called Dirac cone structure) was first visualized in this material.[162][163][164] Weak anti-localization is observed in this material, but not in exfoliated graphene produced by the drawing method.[165] Large, temperature-independent mobilities approach those in exfoliated graphene placed on silicon oxide, but lower than mobilities in suspended graphene produced by the drawing method. Even without transfer, graphene on SiC exhibits massless Dirac fermions.[76][77][78][79][80][81][166]
The weak van der Waals force that provides the cohesion of multilayer graphene stacks does not always affect the electronic properties of the individual layers. That is, while the electronic properties of certain multilayered epitaxial graphenes are identical to that of a single layer,[167] in other cases the properties are affected,[162][163] as they are in bulk graphite. This effect is well understood theoretically and is related to the symmetry of the interlayer interactions.[167]
Epitaxial graphene on SiC can be patterned using standard microelectronics methods. A band gap can be created and tuned by laser irradiation.[168]
Metal substrates
The atomic structure of a metal substrate can seed the growth of graphene.Ruthenium
Graphene grown on ruthenium does not typically produce uniform layer thickness. Bonding between the bottom graphene layer and the substrate may affect layer properties.[169]Iridium
Graphene grown on iridium is very weakly bonded, uniform in thickness and can be highly ordered. As on many other substrates, graphene on iridium is slightly rippled. Due to the long-range order of these ripples, minigaps in the electronic band-structure (Dirac cone) become visible.[170]Nickel
High-quality sheets of few-layer graphene exceeding 1 cm2 (0.2 sq in) in area have been synthesized via chemical vapor deposition on thin nickel films using multiple techniques.The growth of graphene on nickle films through chemical vapor deposition occurs in a few steps. First the thin nickle film is exposed to Argon gas at 900-1000� degrees Celsius. Methane is then mixed into the gas, and the carbon from the methane is absorbed into the nickel film. The nickle-carbon solution is then cooled down in argon gas. During the cooling process the carbon diffuses out of the nickle to form graphene films.[76][171][172][173]
Another used temperatures compatible with conventional CMOS processing, using a nickel-based alloy with gold as catalyst.[174] This process dissolves carbon atoms inside a transition metal melt at a certain temperature and then precipitates the dissolved carbon at lower temperatures as single layer graphene (SLG).
The metal is first melted in contact with a carbon source, possibly a graphite crucible inside which the melt is carried out or graphite powder/chunks that are placed in the melt. Keeping the melt in contact with the carbon at a specific temperature dissolves the carbon atoms, saturating the melt based on the metal-carbon binary phase diagram. Lowering the temperature decreases carbon's solubility and the excess carbon precipitates atop the melt. The floating layer can be either skimmed or frozen for later removal. Using different morphology, including thick graphite, few layer graphene (FLG) and SLG were observed on metal substrate. Raman spectroscopy proved that SLG had grown on nickel substrate. The SLG Raman spectrum featured no D and D′ band, indicating its pristine nature. Since nickel is not Raman active, direct Raman spectroscopy of graphene layers on top of the nickel is achievable.[175]
Another approach covered a sheet of silicon dioxide glass (the substrate) on one side with a nickel film. Graphene deposited via chemical vapor deposition formed into layers on both sides of the film, one on the exposed top side, and one on the underside, sandwiched between nickel and glass. Peeling the nickel and the top layer of graphene left intervening layer of graphene behind on the glass. While the top graphene layer could be harvested from the foil as in earlier methods, the bottom layer was already in place on the glass. The quality and purity of the attached layer was not assessed.[176]
Copper
An improvement of this technique employs copper foil; at very low pressure, the growth of graphene automatically stops after a single graphene layer forms. Arbitrarily large films can be created.[172][177]The single layer growth is also due to the low concentration of carbon in methane. Larger hydrocarbons such as ethane and propane produce bilayer coatings.[178] Atmospheric pressure CVD growth produces multilayer graphene on copper (similar to nickel).[179] Ballistic transport has also been observed in the graphene grown on copper.[180]
Sodium ethoxide pyrolysis
Gram-quantities of graphene were produced by the reduction of ethanol by sodium metal, followed by pyrolysis of the ethoxide product and washing with water to remove sodium salts.[181]Silicon/germanium/hydrogen
A normal silicon wafer coated with a layer of germanium (Ge) dipped in dilute hydrofluoric acid strips the naturally forming germanium oxide groups, creating hydrogen-terminated germanium.Chemical vapor deposition deposits a layer of graphene on top. The graphene can be peeled from the wafer using a dry process and is then ready for use. The wafer can be reused. The graphene is wrinkle-free, high quality and low in defects.[182][183]
Nanotube slicing
Graphene can be created by cutting open carbon nanotubes.[184] In one such method multi-walled carbon nanotubes are cut open in solution by action of potassium permanganate and sulfuric acid.[185] In another method graphene nanoribbons were produced by plasma etching of nanotubes partly embedded in a polymer film.[186]Carbon dioxide reduction
A highly exothermic reaction combusts magnesium in an oxidation-reduction reaction with carbon dioxide, producing a variety of carbon nanoparticles including graphene and fullerenes. The carbon dioxide reactant may be either solid (dry-ice) or gaseous. The products of this reaction are carbon and magnesium oxide. US patent 8377408 was issued for this process.[187]Spin coating
In 2014, carbon nanotube-reinforced graphene was made via spin coating and annealing functionalized carbon nanotubes. The resulting material was stronger, flexible and more conductive than conventional graphene.[142]Supersonic spray
Supersonic acceleration of droplets through a Laval nozzle was used to deposit small droplets of reduced graphene-oxide in suspension on a substrate. The droplets disperse evenly, evaporate rapidly and display reduced flake aggregations. In addition, the topological defects (Stone-Wales defect and C2 vacancies) originally in the flakes disappeared. The result was a higher quality graphene layer.
The energy of the impact stretches the graphene and rearranges its carbon atoms into flawless hexagonal graphene with no need for post-treatment.[188][189]
