History
Broken rifle and Circle-A
Henry David Thoreau
(1817–1862) was an important early influence in individualist anarchist
thought in the United States and Europe. Thoreau's essay "Civil Disobedience" (Resistance to Civil Government) was named as an influence by Mohandas Gandhi, Martin Luther King, Jr., Martin Buber and Leo Tolstoy due to its advocacy of nonviolent resistance. According to the Peace Pledge Union of Britain, it was also the main precedent for anarcho-pacifism.
Thoreau himself did not subscribe to pacifism, and did not reject the
use of armed revolt. He demonstrated this with his unqualified support
for John Brown and other violent abolitionists, writing of Brown that "The question is not about the weapon, but the spirit in which you use it."
In the 1840s, the American abolitionist and advocate of nonresistance Henry Clarke Wright and his English follower Joseph Barker rejected the idea of governments and advocated a form of pacifist individualist anarchism. At some point anarcho-pacifism had as its main proponent Christian anarchism. The Tolstoyan movement in Russia was the first large-scale anarcho-pacifist movement.
Violence has always been controversial in anarchism. While many anarchists embraced violent propaganda of the deed
during the nineteenth century, anarcho-pacifists directly opposed
violence as a means for change. Tolstoy argued that anarchism must be
nonviolent since it is, by definition, opposition to coercion and force,
and that since the state is inherently violent, meaningful pacifism
must likewise be anarchistic. Ferdinand Domela Nieuwenhuis was also instrumental in establishing the pacifist trend within the anarchist movement. In France anti-militarism appeared strongly in individualist anarchist circles, as Émile Armand co-founded "Ligue Antimilitariste" in December 1902 with fellow anarchists Georges Yvetot, Henri Beylie, Paraf-Javal, Albert Libertad and Émile Janvion. The Ligue antimilitariste was to become the French section of the Association internationale antimilitariste (AIA) founded in Amsterdam in 1904.
Dorothy Day, American Christian anarchist and anarcho-pacifist
Bart de Ligt, influential Dutch anarcho-pacifist writer of the theoretical work The Conquest of Violence
Tolstoy's philosophy was cited as a major inspiration by Mohandas Gandhi, an Indian independence leader and pacifist who self-identified as an anarchist. "Gandhi's ideas were popularised in the West in books such as Richard Gregg's The Power of Nonviolence (1935), and Bart de Ligt's The Conquest of Violence
(1937). The latter is particularly important for anarchists since, as
one himself, de Ligt specifically addressed those who lust for
revolution. 'The more violence, the less revolution,' he declared. He
also linked Gandhian principled nonviolence with the pragmatic nonviolent direct action of the syndicalists. (The General Strike
is an expression of total noncooperation by workers, though it should
be added that most syndicalists believed that the revolution should be
defended by armed workers.)" The Conquest of Violence alludes to Kropotkin's The Conquest of Bread.
As a global movement, anarchist pacifism emerged shortly before World War II in the Netherlands, United Kingdom and United States and was a strong presence in the subsequent campaigns for nuclear disarmament. The American writer Dwight Macdonald endorsed anarcho-pacifist views in the 1940s and used his journal politics to promote these ideas.
For Andrew Cornell "Many young anarchists of this period departed from
previous generations both by embracing pacifism and by devoting more
energy to promoting avant-garde culture, preparing the ground for the Beat Generation in the process. The editors of the anarchist journal Retort,
for instance, produced a volume of writings by WWII draft resistors
imprisoned at Danbury, Connecticut, while regularly publishing the
poetry and prose of writers such as Kenneth Rexroth and Norman Mailer.
From the 1940s to the 1960s, then, the radical pacifist movement in the
United States harbored both social democrats and anarchists, at a time
when the anarchist movement itself seemed on its last legs." A leading British anarcho-pacifist was Alex Comfort
who considered himself "an aggressive anti-militarist," and he believed
that pacifism rested "solely upon the historical theory of anarchism." He was an active member of CND.
Among the works on anarchism by Comfort is Peace and Disobedience (1946), one of many pamphlets he wrote for Peace News and the Peace Pledge Union, and Authority and Delinquency in the Modern State (1950). He exchanged public correspondence with George Orwell defending pacifism in the open letter/poem "Letter to an American Visitor" under the pseudonym "Obadiah Hornbrooke."
In the 1950s and 1960s, anarcho-pacifism "began to gel,
tough-minded anarchists adding to the mixture their critique of the
state, and tender-minded pacifists their critique of violence". Within the context of the emergence of the New Left and the Civil Rights Movement,
"several themes, theories, actions, all distinctly libertarian, began
to come to the fore and were given intellectual expression by the
American anarcho-pacifist, Paul Goodman."
Other notable anarcho-pacifist historical figures include Ammon Hennacy, Dorothy Day and, for a brief period between 1939 and 1940, Jean-Paul Sartre. Dorothy Day, (November 8, 1897 – November 29, 1980) was an American journalist, social activist and devout Catholic convert; she advocated the Catholic economic theory of distributism. She was also considered to be an anarchist, and did not hesitate to use the term. In the 1930s, Day worked closely with fellow activist Peter Maurin
to establish the Catholic Worker movement, a nonviolent, pacifist
movement that continues to combine direct aid for the poor and homeless
with nonviolent direct action on their behalf. The cause for Day's canonization is open in the Catholic Church. Ammon Hennacy (July 24, 1893 – January 14, 1970) was an American pacifist, Christian anarchist, vegetarian, social activist, member of the Catholic Worker Movement and a Wobbly. He established the "Joe Hill House of Hospitality" in Salt Lake City, Utah and practiced tax resistance. Charles-Auguste Bontemps was a prolific author mainly in the anarchist, freethinking, pacifist and naturist press of the time. His view on anarchism was based around his concept of "Social Individualism" on which he wrote extensively. He defended an anarchist perspective which consisted on "a collectivism of things and an individualism of persons." Gérard de Lacaze-Duthiers was a French writer, art critic, pacifist and anarchist. Lacaze-Duthiers, an art critic for the Symbolist review journal La Plume, was influenced by Oscar Wilde, Nietzsche and Max Stirner. His (1906) L'Ideal Humain de l'Art helped found the 'Artistocracy' movement - a movement advocating life in the service of art. His ideal was an anti-elitist aestheticism: "All men should be artists". Jean-René Saulière (also René Saulière) (Bordeaux, September 6, 1911- January 2, 1999) was a French anarcho-pacifist, individualist anarchist and free thought writer and militant who went under the pseudonym André Arru. During the late 1950s he establishes inside the Fédération des Libres Penseurs des Bouches du Rhône, the Group Francisco Ferrer and in 1959 he joins the Union des Pacifistes de France (Union of Pacifists of France). From 1968 to 1982, Arru alongside the members of the Group Francisco Ferrer publishes La Libre Pensée des Bouches du Rhône.
Movement for a New Society (MNS), a national network of feminist radical pacifist collectives that existed from 1971 to 1988", is sometimes identified as anarchist, although they did not identify themselves as such.
For Andrew Cornell "MNS popularized consensus decision-making,
introduced the spokescouncil method of organization to activists in the
United States, and was a leading advocate of a variety of
practices—communal living, unlearning oppressive behavior, creating
co-operatively owned businesses—that are now often subsumed under the
rubric of “prefigurative politics.”
MNS leader George Lakey stated that, “The anarchists claim me but I'm
always a little surprised when they do because I'm fond of social democracy as it's been developed in Norway.” (Lakey has supported electoral politics, including the re-election of Barack Obama as U.S. president)
Thought
From "An Anarchist FAQ":
"the attraction of pacifism to anarchists is clear. Violence is
authoritarian and coercive, and so its use does contradict anarchist
principles... (Errico) Malatesta is even more explicit when he wrote that the "main plank of anarchism is the removal of violence from human relations".
Anarcho-pacifists tend to see the state as 'organised violence'
and so they see that "it would therefore seem logical that anarchists
should reject all violence".
Anarcho-pacifism criticizes the separation between means and ends.
"Means... must not merely be consistent with ends; this principle,
though preferable to 'the end justifies the means', is based on a
misleading dichotomy. Means are ends, never merely instrumental but also
always expressive of values; means are end-creating or ends-in-the
making".
An anarcho-pacifist critique of capitalism was provided by Bart de Ligt in his The Conquest of Violence. An Anarchist FAQ
reports how "all anarchists would agree with de Ligt on, to use the
name of one of his book's chapters, "the absurdity of bourgeois
pacifism." For de Ligt, and all anarchists, violence is inherent in the
capitalist system and any attempt to make capitalism pacifistic is
doomed to failure. This is because, on the one hand, war is often just
economic competition carried out by other means. Nations often go to war
when they face an economic crisis, what they cannot gain in economic
struggle they attempt to get by conflict. On the other hand, "violence
is indispensable in modern society... [because] without it the ruling
class would be completely unable to maintain its privileged position
with regard to the exploited masses in each country. The army is used
first and foremost to hold down the workers... when they become
discontented." [Bart de Ligt, Op. Cit., p. 62] As long as the state and
capitalism exist, violence is inevitable and so, for anarcho-pacifists,
the consistent pacifist must be an anarchist just as the consistent
anarchist must be a pacifist".
A main component of anarcho-pacifist strategy is civil disobedience as advocated by the early anarchist thinker Henry David Thoreau in the essay of the same name from 1849 (although Thoreau strongly supported the gun rights and self-defense). Leo Tolstoy
was influenced by it and he saw that a "great weapon for undermining
(rather than overthrowing) the state was the refusal by individuals to
cooperate with it and obey its immoral demands". Also the concepts of passive and active resistance have relevance as they were developed later by Mohandas Gandhi.
For anarchist historian George Woodcock "the modern pacifist anarchists,...have tended to concentrate their attention largely on the creation of libertarian communities -- particularly farming communities -- within present society, as a kind of peaceful version of the propaganda by deed. They divide, however, over the question of action.". Anarcho-pacifists can even accept "the principle of resistance and even revolutionary action (nonviolent revolution), provided it does not incur violence, which they see as a form of power and therefore nonanarchist in
nature. This change in attitude has led the pacifist anarchists to veer toward the anarcho-syndicalists, since the latter's concept of the general strike
as the great revolutionary weapon made an appeal to those pacifists who
accepted the need for fundamental social change but did not wish to
compromise their
ideal by the use of negative (i.e., violent) means."
Ideological variance
While anarcho-pacifism is most commonly associated with religious anarchism such as Tolstoyan Christian anarchism and Buddhist anarchism, irreligious or even anti-religious
tendencies have emerged such as the French individualist anarchist
anarcho-pacifist tendency exemplified by authors and activists such as Charles-Auguste Bontemps, André Arru and Gérard de Lacaze-Duthiers which aligned itself with atheism and freethought. The anarcho-punk band Crass
polemicised a variant of anarcho-pacifism whilst at the same time
explicitly rejecting all religions, especially the symbols of
'establishment' Christian theology.
Opposition to the use of violence has not prohibited anarcho-pacifists
from accepting the principle of resistance or even revolutionary action
provided it does not result in violence; in fact it was their approval
of such forms of opposition to power that lead anarcho-pacifists to
endorse the anarcho-syndicalist concept of the general strike as the great revolutionary weapon. Later anarcho-pacifists have also come to endorse to non-violent strategy of dual power, as championed by Mutualism.
Criticism
Peter Gelderloos
criticizes the idea that nonviolence is the only way to fight for a
better world. According to Gelderloos, pacifism as an ideology serves
the interests of the state and is hopelessly caught up psychologically
with the control schema of patriarchy and white supremacy. The influential publishing collective CrimethInc.
notes that "violence" and "nonviolence" are politicized terms that are
used inconsistently in discourse, depending on whether or not a writer
seeks to legitimize the actor in question. They argue that "[i]t's not
strategic [for anarchists] to focus on delegitimizing each other's
efforts rather than coordinating to act together where we overlap". For
this reason, both CrimethInc. and Gelderloos advocate for diversity of tactics.
