Search This Blog

Thursday, November 19, 2026

First universal common ancestor

The first universal common ancestor (FUCA) is proposed to have been a non-cellular entity that was the earliest organism with a genetic code capable of performing biological translation of RNA molecules to protein formation through peptide synthesis. Its descendants would include the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) and, therefore, all modern cells. FUCA would also be the ancestor of ancient sister lineages of LUCA with no direct modern descendants, but which may have transferred genetic material horizontally into the genomes of early descendants of LUCA.

FUCA is thought to have been composed of progenotes, ancient biological systems that would have used RNA for their genome and self-replication. By comparison, LUCA would have had a complex metabolism and a DNA genome containing hundreds of genes grouped into several gene families.

Origins

Long before compartmentalized biology like FUCA appeared, life is hypothesized to have emerged through the organization of a pre-cellular era in the RNA world. In this era, self-replicating RNA molecules would have both stored genetic information and catalyzed chemical reactions. Translation machinery and the genetic code is universally present in all known cells and viruses, indicating a single origin for biological systems (monophyly).

FUCA is thought to have been the first organism capable of biological translation, using RNA molecules to convert information into peptides and produce proteins. This first translation system is thought to have formed at the same time as an error-prone early genetic code. FUCA would be the first biological system to have a genetic code that dictates specific protein assembly.

The development of FUCA would have been a gradual process initially without the genetic code. FUCA is hypothesized to have arisen from the ribosome, a complex made of RNA and proteins that evolved from a more primitive ribonucleoprotein machinery. FUCA appeared when the early peptidyl transferase center first emerged and when RNA world replicators could bond amino acids into short chained oligopeptides.

The first genes of FUCA most likely encoded ribosomal components, primitive tRNA-aminoacyl transferases, and other proteins that helped stabilize and maintain biological translation. These random peptides may have bound back to the single strand nucleic acid polymers which increased their stability and the robustness of the system, binding other stabilizing molecules. When FUCA matured, its genetic code was then completely established.

It has been proposed that FUCA was composed by a population of open-systems, exchanging components and information with the environment, and a population of self-replicating ribonucleoproteins. The progenote era began when these interaction systems arrived. These systems reached maturity when self-organization processes resulted in the emergence of a genetic code. This genetic code was, for the first time, able to organize an ordered interaction between nucleic acids and proteins through the formation of a biological language. This caused pre-cellular open systems to start to accumulate information and self-organizing, producing the first genomes by the assembling biochemical pathways. The pathways probably appeared in different progenote populations that independently evolved.

Progenotes

Progenotes (also called ribocytes or ribocells) are open or semi-open biological systems capable of intensely exchanging genetic information, before the existence of cells and LUCA. The term progenote was coined by Carl Woese in 1977, around the time he introduced the concept of the three domains of life (bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes). Woese also proposed that each domain originated from a different progenote. The meaning of progenote changed over time, when in the 1980s, Doolittle and Darnell used the term to refer to the single ancestor of all three domains of life, now referred to as the last universal common ancestor (LUCA).

The terms ribocyte and ribocell refer to progenotes as early forms of ribosomes (protoribosomes), hypothetical primitive cellular organisms with self-replicating RNA with an RNA genome instead of the usual DNA genome. In Carl Woese's Darwinian threshold period of cellular evolution, progenotes are also thought to have had RNA rather than DNA as informational molecule.

The evolution of the ribosome from ancient ribocytes, the self-replicating RNA systems and machinery, into its current form as a translation machine may have been the selective pressure to then incorporate proteins into the ribosome's self-replicating mechanisms, which would increase its capacity to self-replicate. Ribosomal RNA is thought to have emerged before cells or viruses, during the time when progenotes existed.

Progenotes both composed FUCA and descended from FUCA. FUCA is thought to have organized the transition from initial biological systems to mature progenotes. Progenotes were the dominant forms during the Progenote age, when biological systems first originated and assembled. The Progenote age would have happened after the pre-biotic RNA-world and Peptide-world ages, but before the emergence and presence of organisms and mature biological systems like viruses, bacteria and archaea.

The most successful progenotes populations were probably the ones capable of binding and processing carbohydrates, amino acids, and other intermediated metabolites and co-factors. In progenotes, there was not complete compartmentalization by membranes and translation of proteins was not precise. Not every progenote had a full metabolism on its own; different metabolic steps occurred in different progenotes. Therefore, it is assumed that there was a community of interacting sub-systems that began to cooperate collectively and eventually culminated in the LUCA.

Ribocytes and viruses

In the eocyte hypothesis linking the closest known archaeal relatives of eukaryotes (achaean eocytes), the organism at the root of the eocytes lineage may have been a ribocyte from the RNA-world. For cellular DNA and DNA processing systems, an "out of virus" scenario has been proposed. In this model, DNA as the main genetic information material may have first evolved in viruses and was later transferred to ribocytes twice: once transforming them into bacteria and once transforming them into archaea.

Similarly in viral eukaryogenesis, a hypothesis theorizing that eukaryotes evolved from a DNA virus, ribocytes may have been an ancient host for a DNA virus. Because ribocytes used RNA to store their genetic information, viruses may initially have used DNA as a way to resist RNA-degrading enzymes present in the host ribocells. The introduction of a DNA-based system may have been as significant for protocells as later additions of chloroplasts or mitochondria through endosymbiosis in evolving eukaryotic cells. In this hypothesis, bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes each obtained their DNA informational system from a different virus.

In the reduction hypothesis, where giant viruses evolved from primordial cells that became parasitic, viruses might have evolved after FUCA but before LUCA.

Alternative abiogenesis scenarios

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_abiogenesis_scenarios

A scenario is a set of related concepts pertinent to the origin of life (abiogenesis), such as the iron-sulfur world. Many alternative abiogenesis scenarios have been proposed by scientists in a variety of fields from the 1950s onwards in an attempt to explain how the complex mechanisms of life could have come into existence. These include hypothesized ancient environments that might have been favourable for the origin of life, and possible biochemical mechanisms.

Environments

Many environments have been proposed for the origin of life.

Fluctuating salinity: dilute and dry-down

Harold Blum noted in 1957 that if proto-nucleic acid chains spontaneously form duplex structures, then there is no way to dissociate them.

The Oparin-Haldane hypothesis addresses the formation, but not the dissociation, of nucleic acid polymers and duplexes. However, nucleic acids are unusual because, in the absence of counterions (low salt) to neutralize the high charges on opposing phosphate groups, the nucleic acid duplex dissociates into single chains. Early tides, driven by a close moon, could have generated rapid cycles of dilution (high tide, low salt) and concentration (dry-down at low tide, high salt) that exclusively promoted the replication of nucleic acids through a process dubbed tidal chain reaction (TCR). This theory has been criticized on the grounds that early tides may not have been so rapid, although regression from current values requires an Earth–Moon juxtaposition at around two Ga, for which there is no evidence, and early tides may have been approximately every seven hours. Another critique is that only 2–3% of the Earth's crust may have been exposed above the sea until late in terrestrial evolution.

The tidal chain reaction theory has mechanistic advantages over thermal association/dissociation at deep-sea vents because it requires that chain assembly (template-driven polymerization) takes place during the dry-down phase, when precursors are most concentrated, whereas thermal cycling needs polymerization to take place during the cold phase, when the rate of chain assembly is lowest and precursors are likely to be more dilute.

Hot freshwater lakes

Jack W. Szostak suggested that geothermal activity provides greater opportunities for the origination of life in open lakes where there is a buildup of minerals. In 2010, based on spectral analysis of sea and hot mineral water, Ignat Ignatov and Oleg Mosin demonstrated that life may have predominantly originated in hot mineral water. Hot mineral water that contains hydrogen carbonate and calcium ions has the most optimal range. This case is similar to the origin of life in hydrothermal vents, but with hydrogen carbonate and calcium ions in hot water. The main studies were conducted in Rupite, Bulgaria, where a novel thermophylic bacterium Anoxybacillus rupiences sp. Nov. and cyanobacteria were identified. At a pH of 9–11, the reactions can take place in seawater. According to Melvin Calvin, certain reactions of condensation-dehydration of amino acids and nucleotides in individual blocks of peptides and nucleic acids can take place in the primary hydrosphere with pH 9–11 at a later evolutionary stage. Some of these compounds like hydrocyanic acid (HCN) have been proven in the experiments of Miller. This is the environment in which the stromatolites have been created. David Ward described the formation of stromatolites in hot mineral water at the Yellowstone National Park. In 2011, Tadashi Sugawara created a protocell in hot water.

Geothermal springs

Bruce Damer and David Deamer argue that cell membranes cannot be formed in salty seawater, and must therefore have originated in freshwater environments like pools replenished by a combination of geothermal springs and rainfall. Before the continents formed, the only dry land on Earth would be volcanic islands, where rainwater would form ponds where lipids could form the first stages towards cell membranes. During multiple wet-dry cycles, biopolymers would be synthesized and are encapsulated in vesicles after condensation. Zinc sulfide and manganese sulfide in these ponds would have catalyzed organic compounds by abiotic photosynthesis. Experimental research at geothermal springs successfully synthesized polymers and were encapsulated in vesicles after exposure to UV light and multiple wet-dry cycles. At temperatures of 60 to 80 °C at geothermal fields, biochemical reactions can occur. These predecessors of true cells are assumed to have behaved more like a superorganism rather than individual structures, where the porous membranes would house molecules which would leak out and enter other protocells. Only when true cells had evolved would they gradually adapt to saltier environments and enter the ocean.

6 of the 11 biochemical reactions of the rTCA cycle can occur in hot metal-rich acidic water which suggests metabolic reactions might have originated in this environment, this is consistent with the enhanced stability of RNA phosphodiester, aminoacyl-tRNA bonds, and peptides in acidic conditions. Cycling between supercritical and subcritical CO2 at tectonic fault zones might have led to peptides integrating with and stabilizing lipid membranes. This is suggested to have driven membrane protein evolution, as it shown that a selected peptide (H-Lys-Ser-Pro-Phe-Pro-Phe-Ala-Ala-OH) causes the increase of membrane permeability to water. David Deamer and Bruce Damer states that the prebiotic chemistry does not require ultraviolet irradiation as the chemistry could also have occurred under shaded areas that protected biomolecules from photolysis.

Deep sea alkaline vents

Nick Lane believes that no known life forms could have utilized zinc-sulfide based photosynthesis, lightning, volcanic pyrite synthesis, or UV radiation as a source of energy. Rather, he instead suggests that deep sea alkaline vents is more likely to have been a source energy for early cellular life. Serpentinization at alkaline hydrothermal vents produce methane and ammonia. Mineral particles that have similar properties to enzymes at deep sea vents would catalyze organic compounds out of dissolved CO2 within seawater. Porous rock might have promoted condensation reactions of biopolymers and act as a compartment of membranous structures, however it is unknown about how it could promote coding and metabolism. Acetyl phosphate, which is readily synthesized from thioacetate, can promote aggregation of adenosine monophosphate of up to 7 monomers which is considered energetically favored in water due to interactions between nucleobases. Acetyl phosphate can stabilize aggregation of nucleotides in the presence of Na+ and could possibly promote polymerization at mineral surfaces or lower water activity. An external proton gradient within a membrane would have been maintained between the acidic ocean and alkaline seawater. The descendants of the last universal common ancestor, bacteria and archaea, were probably methanogens and acetogens. The earliest microfossils, dated to be 4.28 to 3.77 Ga, were found at hydrothermal vent precipitates. These microfossils suggest that early cellular life began at deep sea hydrothermal vents. Exergonic reactions at these environments could have provided free energy that promoted chemical reactions conducive to prebiotic biomolecules.

Nonenzymatic reactions of glycolysis and the pentose phosphate pathway can occur in the presence of ferrous iron at 70 °C, the reactions produce erythrose 4-phosphate, an amino acid precursor and ribose 5-phosphate, a nucleotide precursor. Pyrimidines are shown to be synthesized from the reaction between aspartate and carbamoyl phosphate at 60 °C and in the presence of metals, it is suggested that purines could be synthesized from the catalysis of metals. Adenosine monophosphate are also shown to be synthesized from adenine, monopotassium phosphate or pyrophosphate, and ribose at silica at 70 °C. Reductive amination and transamination reactions catalyzed by alkaline hydrothermal vent mineral and metal ions produce amino acids. Long chain fatty acids can be derived from formic acid or oxalic acid during Fischer-Tropsch-type synthesis. Carbohydrates containing an isoprene skeleton can be synthesized from the formose reaction. Isoprenoids incorporated into fatty acid vesicles can stabilize the vesicles, which are suggested to have driven the divergence of bacterial and archaeal lipids.

A scenario

Lane has proposed a possible scenario for the origin of life that integrates much of the available evidence from biochemistry, geology, phylogeny, and experimentation:

Volcanic ash in the ocean

Geoffrey W. Hoffmann has argued that a complex nucleation event as the origin of life involving both polypeptides and nucleic acid is compatible with the time and space available in the primary oceans of Earth. Hoffmann suggests that volcanic ash may provide the many random shapes needed in the postulated complex nucleation event. This aspect of the theory can be tested experimentally.

Gold's deep-hot biosphere

In the 1970s, Thomas Gold proposed the theory that life first developed not on the surface of the Earth, but several kilometers below the surface. It is claimed that the discovery of microbial life below the surface of another body in our Solar System would lend significant credence to this theory.

Radioactive beach hypothesis

Zachary Adam claims that tidal processes that occurred during a time when the Moon was much closer may have concentrated grains of uranium and other radioactive elements at the high-water mark on primordial beaches, where they may have been responsible for generating life's building blocks. According to computer models, a deposit of such radioactive materials could show the same self-sustaining nuclear reaction as that found in the Oklo uranium ore seam in Gabon. Such radioactive beach sand might have provided sufficient energy to generate organic molecules, such as amino acids and sugars from acetonitrile in water. Radioactive monazite material also has released soluble phosphate into the regions between sand-grains, making it biologically "accessible." Thus amino acids, sugars, and soluble phosphates might have been produced simultaneously, according to Adam. Radioactive actinides, left behind in some concentration by the reaction, might have formed part of organometallic complexes. These complexes could have been important early catalysts to living processes.

John Parnell has suggested that such a process could provide part of the "crucible of life" in the early stages of any early wet rocky planet, so long as the planet is large enough to have generated a system of plate tectonics which brings radioactive minerals to the surface. As the early Earth is thought to have had many smaller plates, it might have provided a suitable environment for such processes.

The hypercycle

In the early 1970s, Manfred Eigen and Peter Schuster examined the transient stages between the molecular chaos and a self-replicating hypercycle in a prebiotic soup. In a hypercycle, the information storing system (possibly RNA) produces an enzyme, which catalyzes the formation of another information system, in sequence until the product of the last aids in the formation of the first information system. Mathematically treated, hypercycles could create quasispecies, which through natural selection entered into a form of Darwinian evolution. A boost to hypercycle theory was the discovery of ribozymes capable of catalyzing their own chemical reactions. The hypercycle theory requires the existence of complex biochemicals, such as nucleotides, which do not form under the conditions proposed by the Miller–Urey experiment.

Iron–sulfur world

In the 1980s, Wächtershäuser and Karl Popper postulated the iron–sulfur world hypothesis for the evolution of pre-biotic chemical pathways. It traces today's biochemistry to primordial reactions which synthesize organic building blocks from gases. Wächtershäuser systems have a built-in source of energy: iron sulfides such as pyrite. The energy released by oxidising these metal sulfides can support synthesis of organic molecules. Such systems may have evolved into autocatalytic sets constituting self-replicating, metabolically active entities predating modern life forms. Experiments with sulfides in an aqueous environment at 100 °C produced a small yield of dipeptides (0.4% to 12.4%) and a smaller yield of tripeptides (0.10%). However, under the same conditions, dipeptides were quickly broken down.

Several models postulate a primitive metabolism, allowing RNA replication to emerge later. The centrality of the Krebs cycle (citric acid cycle) to energy production in aerobic organisms, and in drawing in carbon dioxide and hydrogen ions in biosynthesis of complex organic chemicals, suggests that it was one of the first parts of the metabolism to evolve. Concordantly, geochemists Szostak and Kate Adamala demonstrated that non-enzymatic RNA replication in primitive protocells is only possible in the presence of weak cation chelators like citric acid. This provides further evidence for the central role of citric acid in primordial metabolism. Russell has proposed that "the purpose of life is to hydrogenate carbon dioxide" (as part of a "metabolism-first", rather than a "genetics-first", scenario). The physicist Jeremy England has argued from general thermodynamic considerations that life was inevitable. An early version of this idea was Oparin's 1924 proposal for self-replicating vesicles. In the 1980s and 1990s came Wächtershäuser's iron–sulfur world theory and Christian de Duve's thioester models. More abstract and theoretical arguments for metabolism without genes include Freeman Dyson's mathematical model and Stuart Kauffman's collectively autocatalytic sets in the 1980s. Kauffman's work has been criticized for ignoring the role of energy in driving biochemical reactions in cells.

The active site of the acetyl-CoA synthase enzyme, part of the acetyl-CoA pathway, contains nickel-iron-sulfur clusters.

A multistep biochemical pathway like the Krebs cycle did not just self-organize on the surface of a mineral; it must have been preceded by simpler pathways. The Wood–Ljungdahl pathway is compatible with self-organization on a metal sulfide surface. Its key enzyme unit, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase, contains mixed nickel-iron-sulfur clusters in its reaction centers and catalyzes the formation of acetyl-CoA. However, prebiotic thiolated and thioester compounds are thermodynamically and kinetically unlikely to accumulate in the presumed prebiotic conditions of hydrothermal vents. One possibility is that cysteine and homocysteine may have reacted with nitriles from the Strecker reaction, forming catalytic thiol-rich polypeptides.

It has been suggested that the iron-sulfur world hypothesis and RNA world hypothesis are not mutually exclusive as modern cellular processes do involve both metabolites and genetic molecules.

Zinc world

Armen Mulkidjanian's zinc world (Zn-world) hypothesis extends Wächtershäuser's pyrite hypothesis. The Zn-world theory proposes that hydrothermal fluids rich in H2S interacting with cold primordial ocean (or Darwin's "warm little pond") water precipitated metal sulfide particles. Oceanic hydrothermal systems have a zonal structure reflected in ancient volcanogenic massive sulfide ore deposits. They reach many kilometers in diameter and date back to the Archean. Most abundant are pyrite (FeS2), chalcopyrite (CuFeS2), and sphalerite (ZnS), with additions of galena (PbS) and alabandite (MnS). ZnS and MnS have a unique ability to store radiation energy, e.g. from ultraviolet light. When replicating molecules were originating, the primordial atmospheric pressure was high enough (>100 bar) to precipitate near the Earth's surface, and ultraviolet irradiation was 10 to 100 times more intense than now; hence the photosynthetic properties mediated by ZnS provided the right energy conditions for the synthesis of informational and metabolic molecules and the selection of photostable nucleobases.

The Zn-world theory has been filled out with evidence for the ionic constitution of the interior of the first protocells. In 1926, the Canadian biochemist Archibald Macallum noted the resemblance of body fluids such as blood and lymph to seawater; however, the inorganic composition of all cells differ from that of modern seawater, which led Mulkidjanian and colleagues to reconstruct the "hatcheries" of the first cells combining geochemical analysis with phylogenomic scrutiny of the inorganic ion requirements of modern cells. The authors conclude that ubiquitous, and by inference primordial, proteins and functional systems show affinity to and functional requirement for K+, Zn2+, Mn2+, and [PO
4
]3−
. Geochemical reconstruction shows that this ionic composition could not have existed in the ocean but is compatible with inland geothermal systems. In the oxygen-depleted, CO2-dominated primordial atmosphere, the chemistry of water condensates near geothermal fields would resemble the internal milieu of modern cells. Therefore, precellular evolution may have taken place in shallow "Darwin ponds" lined with porous silicate minerals mixed with metal sulfides and enriched in K+, Zn2+, and phosphorus compounds.

Clay

The clay hypothesis was proposed by Graham Cairns-Smith in 1985. It postulates that complex organic molecules arose gradually on pre-existing, non-organic replication surfaces of silicate crystals in contact with an aqueous solution. The clay mineral montmorillonite has been shown to catalyze the polymerization of RNA in aqueous solution from nucleotide monomers, and the formation of membranes from lipids. In 1998, Hyman Hartman proposed that "the first organisms were self-replicating iron-rich clays which fixed carbon dioxide into oxalic acid and other dicarboxylic acids. This system of replicating clays and their metabolic phenotype then evolved into the sulfide rich region of the hot spring acquiring the ability to fix nitrogen. Finally phosphate was incorporated into the evolving system which allowed the synthesis of nucleotides and phospholipids."

Biochemistry

Different forms of life with variable origin processes may have appeared quasi-simultaneously in the early Earth. The other forms may be extinct, having left distinctive fossils through their different biochemistry. Metabolism-like reactions could have occurred naturally in early oceans, before the first organisms evolved. Some of these reactions can produce RNA, and others resemble two essential reaction cascades of metabolism: glycolysis and the pentose phosphate pathway, that provide essential precursors for nucleic acids, amino acids and lipids.

Fox proteinoids

In trying to uncover the intermediate stages of abiogenesis mentioned by Bernal, Sidney Fox in the 1950s and 1960s studied the spontaneous formation of peptide structures under plausibly early Earth conditions. In one of his experiments, he allowed amino acids to dry out as if puddled in a warm, dry spot in prebiotic conditions: In an experiment to set suitable conditions for life to form, Fox collected volcanic material from a cinder cone in Hawaii. He discovered that the temperature was over 100 °C just 4 inches (100 mm) beneath the surface of the cinder cone, and suggested that this might have been the environment in which life was created—molecules could have formed and then been washed through the loose volcanic ash into the sea. He placed lumps of lava over amino acids derived from methane, ammonia and water, sterilized all materials, and baked the lava over the amino acids for a few hours in a glass oven. A brown, sticky substance formed over the surface, and when the lava was drenched in sterilized water, a thick, brown liquid leached out. He found that, as they dried, the amino acids formed long, often cross-linked, thread-like, submicroscopic polypeptides.

Protein amyloid

An origin-of-life theory based on self-replicating beta-sheet structures has been put forward by Maury in 2009. The theory suggests that self-replicating and self-assembling catalytic amyloids were the first informational polymers in a primitive pre-RNA world. The main arguments for the amyloid hypothesis is based on the structural stability, autocatalytic and catalytic properties, and evolvability of beta-sheet based informational systems. Such systems are also error correcting and chiroselective.

First protein that condenses substrates during thermal cycling: thermosynthesis

Convection cells in fluid placed in a gravity field are selforganizing and enable thermal cycling of the suspended contents in the fluid such as protocells containing protoenzymes that work on thermal cycling.

The thermosynthesis hypothesis considers chemiosmosis more basal than fermentation: the ATP synthase enzyme, which sustains chemiosmosis, is the currently extant enzyme most closely related to the first metabolic process. The thermosynthesis hypothesis does not even invoke a pathway: ATP synthase's binding change mechanism resembles a physical adsorption process that yields free energy. The result would be convection which would bring a continual supply of reactants to the protoenzyme. The described first protein may be simple in the sense that it requires only a short sequence of conserved amino acid residues, a sequent sufficient for the appropriate catalytic cleft.

Pre-RNA world: The ribose issue and its bypass

A different type of nucleic acid, such as peptide nucleic acid, threose nucleic acid or glycol nucleic acid, could have been the first to emerge as a self-reproducing molecule, later replaced by RNA. Larralde et al., say that "the generally accepted prebiotic synthesis of ribose, the formose reaction, yields numerous sugars without any selectivity". They conclude that "the backbone of the first genetic material could not have contained ribose or other sugars because of their instability", meaning that the ester linkage of ribose and phosphoric acid in RNA is prone to hydrolysis.

Pyrimidine ribonucleosides and nucleotides have been synthesized by reactions which by-pass the free sugars, and are assembled stepwise using nitrogenous or oxygenous chemistries. Sutherland has demonstrated high-yielding routes to cytidine and uridine ribonucleotides from small 2 and 3 carbon fragments such as glycolaldehyde, glyceraldehyde or glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate, cyanamide and cyanoacetylene. A step in this sequence allows the isolation of enantiopure ribose aminooxazoline if the enantiomeric excess of glyceraldehyde is 60% or greater. This can be viewed as a prebiotic purification step. Ribose aminooxazoline can then react with cyanoacetylene to give alpha cytidine ribonucleotide. Photoanomerization with UV light allows for inversion about the 1' anomeric centre to give the correct beta stereochemistry. In 2009 they showed that the same simple building blocks allow access, via phosphate controlled nucleobase elaboration, to 2',3'-cyclic pyrimidine nucleotides directly, which can polymerize into RNA. Similar photo-sanitization can create pyrimidine-2',3'-cyclic phosphates.

Autocatalysis

Autocatalysts are substances that catalyze the production of themselves and therefore are "molecular replicators." The simplest self-replicating chemical systems are autocatalytic, and typically contain three components: a product molecule and two precursor molecules. The product molecule joins the precursor molecules, which in turn produce more product molecules from more precursor molecules. The product molecule catalyzes the reaction by providing a complementary template that binds to the precursors, thus bringing them together. Such systems have been demonstrated both in biological macromolecules and in small organic molecules.

It has been proposed that life initially arose as autocatalytic chemical networks. Julius Rebek and colleagues combined amino adenosine and pentafluorophenyl esters with the autocatalyst amino adenosine triacid ester (AATE). One product was a variant of AATE which catalyzed its own synthesis. This demonstrated that autocatalysts could compete within a population of entities with heredity, a rudimentary form of natural selection.

Synthesis based on hydrogen cyanide

A research project completed in 2015 by John Sutherland and others found that a network of reactions beginning with hydrogen cyanide and hydrogen sulfide, in streams of water irradiated by UV light, could produce the chemical components of proteins and lipids, as well as those of RNA, while not producing a wide range of other compounds. The researchers used the term "cyanosulfidic" to describe this network of reactions.

Simulated chemical pathways

In 2020, chemists described possible chemical pathways from nonliving prebiotic chemicals to complex biochemicals that could give rise to living organisms, based on a new computer program named AllChemy.

Viral origin

Evidence for a "virus first" or "virus world" hypothesis, which may support theories of the RNA world, was suggested in 2015. One of the difficulties for the study of the origins of viruses is their high rate of mutation; this is particularly the case in RNA retroviruses like HIV. A 2015 study compared protein fold structures across different branches of the tree of life, where researchers can reconstruct the evolutionary histories of the folds and of the organisms whose genomes code for those folds. They argue that protein folds are better markers of ancient events as their three-dimensional structures can be maintained even as the sequences that code for those begin to change. Thus, the viral protein repertoire retain traces of ancient evolutionary history that can be recovered using advanced bioinformatics approaches. Those researchers think that "the prolonged pressure of genome and particle size reduction eventually reduced virocells into modern viruses (identified by the complete loss of cellular makeup), meanwhile other coexisting cellular lineages diversified into modern cells." The data suggest that viruses originated from ancient cells that co-existed with the ancestors of modern cells. These ancient cells likely contained segmented RNA genomes.

A computational model (2015) has shown that virus capsids may have originated in the RNA world and served as a means of horizontal transfer between replicator communities. These communities could not survive if the number of gene parasites increased, with certain genes being responsible for the formation of these structures and those that favored the survival of self-replicating communities. The displacement of these ancestral genes between cellular organisms could favor the appearance of new viruses during evolution. Viruses retain a replication module inherited from the prebiotic stage since it is absent in cells. So this is evidence that viruses could originate from the RNA world and could also emerge several times in evolution through genetic escape in cells.

Encapsulation without a membrane

Polyester droplets

Tony Jia and Kuhan Chandru have proposed spontaneously-forming membraneless polyester droplets in early cellularization before the innovation of lipid vesicles. Protein function within and RNA function in the presence of certain polyester droplets was shown to be preserved within the droplets. The droplets have scaffolding ability, by allowing lipids to assemble around them; this may have prevented leakage of genetic materials.

Proteinoid microspheres

Fox observed in the 1960s that proteinoids could form cell-like structures named "proteinoid microspheres". The amino acids had combined to form proteinoids, which formed small globules. These were not cells; their clumps and chains were reminiscent of cyanobacteria, but they contained no functional nucleic acids or other encoded information. Colin Pittendrigh stated in 1967 that "laboratories will be creating a living cell within ten years", a remark that reflected the typical contemporary naivety about the complexity of cell structures.

Jeewanu protocell

A further protocell model is the Jeewanu. First synthesized in 1963 from simple minerals and basic organics while exposed to sunlight, it is reported to have some metabolic capabilities, the presence of a semipermeable membrane, amino acids, phospholipids, carbohydrates and RNA-like molecules. However, the nature and properties of the Jeewanu remains to be clarified. Electrostatic interactions induced by short, positively charged, hydrophobic peptides containing 7 amino acids in length or fewer can attach RNA to a vesicle membrane, the basic cell membrane.

RNA-DNA world

In 2020, coevolution of a RNA-DNA mixture based on diamidophosphate was proposed. The mixture of RNA-DNA sequences, called chimeras, have weak affinity and form weaker duplex structures. This is advantageous in an abiotic scenario and these chimeras have been shown to replicate RNA and DNA – overcoming the "template-product" inhibition problem, where a pure RNA or pure DNA strand is unable to replicate non-enzymatically because it binds too strongly to its partners. This could lead to an abiotic cross-catalytic amplification of RNA and DNA. A continuous chemical reaction network in water and under high-energy radiation can generate precursors for early RNA.

In 2022, evolution experiments of self-replicating RNA showed how RNA may have evolved to diverse complex molecules in RNA world conditions. The RNA evolved to a "replicator network comprising five types of RNAs with diverse interactions" such as cooperation for replication of other members (multiple coexisting host and parasite lineages).

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Computer-assisted proof

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer-assisted_proof

A computer-assisted proof is a mathematical proof that has been at least partially generated by computer.

Most computer-aided proofs to date have been implementations of large proofs-by-exhaustion of a mathematical theorem. The idea is to use a computer program to perform lengthy computations, and to provide a proof that the result of these computations implies the given theorem. In 1976, the four color theorem was the first major theorem to be verified using a computer program.

Attempts have also been made in the area of artificial intelligence research to create smaller, explicit, new proofs of mathematical theorems from the bottom up using automated reasoning techniques such as heuristic search. Such automated theorem provers have proved a number of new results and found new proofs for known theorems. Additionally, interactive proof assistants allow mathematicians to develop human-readable proofs which are nonetheless formally verified for correctness. Since these proofs are generally human-surveyable (albeit with difficulty, as with the proof of the Robbins conjecture) they do not share the controversial implications of computer-aided proofs-by-exhaustion.

Methods

One method for using computers in mathematical proofs is by means of so-called validated numerics or rigorous numerics. This means computing numerically yet with mathematical rigour. One uses set-valued arithmetic and inclusion principle in order to ensure that the set-valued output of a numerical program encloses the solution of the original mathematical problem. This is done by controlling, enclosing and propagating round-off and truncation errors using for example interval arithmetic. More precisely, one reduces the computation to a sequence of elementary operations, say . In a computer, the result of each elementary operation is rounded off by the computer precision. However, one can construct an interval provided by upper and lower bounds on the result of an elementary operation. Then one proceeds by replacing numbers with intervals and performing elementary operations between such intervals of representable numbers.

Philosophical objections

Computer-assisted proofs are the subject of some controversy in the mathematical world, with Thomas Tymoczko first to articulate objections. Those who adhere to Tymoczko's arguments believe that lengthy computer-assisted proofs are not, in some sense, 'real' mathematical proofs because they involve so many logical steps that they are not practically verifiable by human beings, and that mathematicians are effectively being asked to replace logical deduction from assumed axioms with trust in an empirical computational process, which is potentially affected by errors in the computer program, as well as defects in the runtime environment and hardware.

Other mathematicians believe that lengthy computer-assisted proofs should be regarded as calculations, rather than proofs: the proof algorithm itself should be proved valid, so that its use can then be regarded as a mere "verification". Arguments that computer-assisted proofs are subject to errors in their source programs, compilers, and hardware can be resolved by providing a formal proof of correctness for the computer program (an approach which was successfully applied to the four color theorem in 2005) as well as replicating the result using different programming languages, different compilers, and different computer hardware.

Another possible way of verifying computer-aided proofs is to generate their reasoning steps in a machine readable form, and then use a proof checker program to demonstrate their correctness. Since validating a given proof is much easier than finding a proof, the checker program is simpler than the original assistant program, and it is correspondingly easier to gain confidence into its correctness. However, this approach of using a computer program to prove the output of another program correct does not appeal to computer proof skeptics, who see it as adding another layer of complexity without addressing the perceived need for human understanding.

Another argument against computer-aided proofs is that they lack mathematical elegance, i.e. that they provide no insights or new and useful concepts. This is an argument which could be advanced against any lengthy proof by exhaustion whatsoever.

An additional philosophical issue raised by computer-aided proofs is whether they make mathematics into a quasi-empirical science, where the scientific method becomes more important than the application of pure reason in the area of abstract mathematical concepts. This directly relates to the argument within mathematics as to whether mathematics is based on ideas, or "merely" an exercise in formal symbol manipulation. It also raises the question whether, if according to the Platonist view, all possible mathematical objects in some sense "already exist", whether computer-aided mathematics is an observational science like astronomy, rather than an experimental one like physics or chemistry. This controversy within mathematics is occurring at the same time as questions are being asked in the physics community about whether twenty-first century theoretical physics is becoming too mathematical, and leaving behind its experimental roots.

The emerging field of experimental mathematics is confronting this debate head-on by focusing on numerical experiments as its main tool for mathematical exploration.

Critical rationalism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_rationalism

Critical rationalism is Karl Popper's answer to what he considered the most important problems of epistemology and philosophy of science: the problems of the growth of knowledge, notably by induction, and the demarcation of science. He adopted a fallibilist approach to these problems, especially that of induction, without falling into skepticism. His approach was to put in perspective the distinctive role of deductive logic in the development of knowledge, especially in science, in the context of a less rigorous methodology based on critical thinking. The central technical concept in the application of critical rationalism to science is falsifiability. Popper first mentioned the term "critical rationalism" in The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945) and also later in Conjectures and Refutations (1963), Unended Quest (1976), and The Myth of the Framework (1994).

Fallibilism, not skepticism

Popper admitted that the truth of statements cannot be obtained using only logical definitions and deductions, as this leads to an infinite regress. For Popper, this does not prevent statements from being useful for solving problems, because they can be logically analyzed to draw logical consequences, possibly contradictions with observation statements linked to real tests. Popper wrote that the bulk of scientific activities use deductive logic to evaluate theories.

Popper accepted Hume's argument and the consequences of Duhem's thesis and insisted that there is no logical method for accessing empirical truth, no inductive rule, not even to a small extent. However, he rejected skepticism, the idea that the search for truth is futile. He admitted that, although logic alone says nothing about empirical truth, statements can be related to reality through problem solving, scientific observations and experiments. Popper always insisted on this distinction between the logical aspect and methodological aspect of science. In Realism and the Aim of Science, Popper speaks of a "preferred" theory, not of a "true" or a "false" theory, when one theory is chosen over another given experimental results.

Tarski's semantic theory of truth

Alfred Tarski inspired Popper with his semantic theory of truth.

In the early twentieth century, discussions of the truth of statements addressed different aspects, including the correspondence of statements with reality, their coherence with other statements, and their practical role in inquiry. Correspondence was an important way of conceiving truth because it made the truth of a statement depend on what was actually the case, independently of what was believed about it. However, for both Russell and Tarski, this conception encounters a fundamental difficulty: it is unclear what a relation of correspondence between a linguistic statement and reality could consist in, or how such a relation could constitute the statement's truth.

The same obstacle lay at the heart of the Vienna Circle's discussions of protocol statements, although its members differed over how it should be addressed. In his first major work in the philosophy of science, before Tarski published his work on truth, Popper had already described the same obstacle: logical justification can relate a statement only to other statements, whereas an appeal to experience or to “immediate knowledge” introduces a subjective and psychological element. In The Logic of Scientific Discovery, he observed that statements can be logically justified only by other statements, while the relation between basic statements and perceptual experiences remained obscure.

Tarski had shown how truth could be defined for certain formalized languages by means of a metalanguage in which it was possible to speak both of the expressions of the language under study and of their satisfaction in an interpretation. He nevertheless presented this conception as neutral with respect to metaphysical positions such as realism and idealism. Tarski's conception provided no general criterion for determining whether a statement corresponds to the facts.

Nevertheless, Popper wrote that Tarski's semantic theory had rehabilitated the conception of objective truth as correspondence with facts, recognizing that this truth could not be inferred from the empirical criteria used to evaluate a theory. Popper was aware that Tarski presented his semantic conception as philosophically neutral, but rejected this assessment and regarded Tarski's result as supporting a realist perspective: it made it possible to distinguish the objective truth of a theory from the always fallible reasons for preferring it. For Popper, the role of methodology was to compensate, at the practical level, for the absence of a general criterion by which correspondence with the facts could be established: guided by truth as a regulative ideal, methodology subjected theories to criticism and to tests capable of revealing their errors.

Popper also related certain distinctions in the philosophy of science to the semantic organization proposed by Tarski. In Realism and the Aim of Science, he thus distinguishes the logical versions of the problem of induction from its metaphysical versions: the latter belong, in his view, to a “meta-theory of physics”, which he compares to what Tarski calls the “semantics of physics”.

The role of methodology

Popper wrote that the bulk of scientific activity takes place in its logical part, using deductive logic to check the consistency of a theory, compare theories, check their empirical nature (i.e., falsifiability) and, most importantly, test a theory, which is possible only when it is falsifiable. He emphasized that, even when theories are tested against observations, deductive logic is largely used.

However, for Popper, this logical part of science must be integrated within an adequate methodology. Popper and the members of the Vienna Circle agreed that only statements can be used to justify statements, that is, the use of logic alone in science will not be linked to (empirical, not propositional) evidence. Logic uses accepted or provisionally accepted observation statements to determine whether a theory is logically refuted or not, but the "accepted" observation statement could be empirically false and that will not concern the logical part.

Popper wrote that any criterion, including his famous falsifiability criterion, that applies solely on the logical structure could not alone define science. In The Logic of Scientific Discovery, he wrote that "it is impossible to decide, by analysing its logical form [as do the falsifiability criterion], whether a system of statements is a conventional system of irrefutable implicit definitions, or whether it is a system which is empirical in my sense; that is, a refutable system". Popper insisted that falsifiability is a logical criterion, which must be understood in the context of a proper methodology.

Popper's methodology proposes the adoption of specific procedures and modes of behavior that align with our aim of finding the truth (not in the Nietzschean sense) or advancing knowledge.

Lakatos described the aspects of scientific methodology leading to the rejection of research programs and their theories

This methodology proposes favoring the most falsifiable theories, but Popper explains that it is not itself falsifiable. Regarding the rule favoring the most falsifiable (least probable) statements, Popper wrote: "it is a mistake to say [...] that I have ever proposed an improbability criterion for the choice of scientific hypotheses: not only do I have no general 'criterion', it happens quite often that I cannot prefer the logically 'better' and more improbable hypothesis, because somebody succeeded in refuting it experimentally". The rule is nevertheless practical, because it says that in "many cases, the more improbable hypothesis is preferable".

Lakatos’s vision of scientific methodology (akin to Popper’s) was a set of informal, implicit conventions guiding all decisions surrounding logical work—which experiments to conduct, which apparatus to build, which field to fund, and so on.

Popper's philosophy was criticized as if the logical part existed alone. For example, Putnam attributed to Popper "the fantasy of doing science using only deductive logic". Putnam further criticized Popper's description of the logical part of science by referring to methodological problems. For example, he wrote: "I claim: in a great many important cases, scientific theories do not imply predictions at all." Because Popper does not believe in inductive logic, Wesley Salmon wrote that, for Popper, "there is no ampliative form of scientific argument, and consequently, science provides no information whatever about the future". Regarding the methodological part, Feyerabend wrote that there is no method in science. He considered and rejected methodological rules, but they were those of a naive falsificationist.

In contrast, Popper emphasized both parts of science and spoke of methodology as a means of correctly using falsifiability and the usual logical work in science to make it useful in a method of conjectures and refutations to be used in usual critical discussions. Falsifiability says hypotheses should be consistent and they should logically lead to predictions, which confrontation with observations should be considered in critical thinking.

Marxism and politics

Adolf Hitler giving speech on March 15, 1938 in Heldenplatz, three days after the Anschluss.

The failure of democratic parties to prevent fascism from taking over Austrian politics in the 1920s and 1930s traumatised Popper. He suffered from the direct consequences of this failure. Events after the Anschluss (the annexation of Austria by the German Reich in 1938) prompted him to refocus his writings on social and political philosophy. His most important works in the field of social science—The Poverty of Historicism (1944) and The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945)—were inspired by his reflection on the events of his time and represented, in a sense, a reaction to the prevalent totalitarian ideologies that then dominated Central European politics. His books defended democratic liberalism as a social and political philosophy. They also represented extensive critiques of the philosophical presuppositions underpinning all forms of totalitarianism.

Earlier in his life, the death of friends in a demonstration instigated by the communists when he was about seventeen strongly contributed to Popper's position regarding the search for contradictions or criticisms and the attitude of taking them into account. He had at one point joined a socialist association, and for a few months in 1919 considered himself a communist. Although it is known that Popper worked as an office boy at the communist headquarters, whether or not he ever became a member of the Communist Party is unclear. During this time he became familiar with the Marxist view of economics, class conflict, and history. He blamed Marxism, which thesis, Popper recalls, "is that although the revolution may claim some victims, capitalism is claiming more victims than the whole socialist revolution". He asked himself "whether such a calculation could ever be supported by 'science'". He then decided that criticism was important in science. This, Popper wrote, made him "a fallibilist", and impressed on him "the value of intellectual modesty". It made him "most conscious of the differences between dogmatic and critical thinking".

Psychoanalysis

Sigmund Freud developed the theories of "Psychoanalysis". Popper considered these theories to be unscientific because they were not falsifiable.

Popper saw a contrast between the theories of Sigmund Freud and Alfred Adler, which he considered unscientific, and Albert Einstein's theory of relativity which sparked the revolution in physics in the early 20th century. Popper believed that Einstein's theory, as a theory properly grounded in scientific thought and method, was highly "risky", in the sense that it was possible to deduce consequences from it that differed considerably from those of the then-dominant Newtonian physics. One such prediction, that gravity could deflect light, was verified by Eddington's experiments in 1919. When he tackled the problem of demarcation in the philosophy of science, he realized that "what made a theory, or a statement, scientific was its power to rule out, or exclude, the occurrence of some possible events—to prohibit, or forbid, the occurrence of these events". He thought that, in contrast, nothing could, even in principle, falsify psychoanalytic theories. This led him to posit that "only attempted refutations which did not succeed qua refutations should count as 'verifications'".

A little later, Popper realized that theories can be "immunized" against falsification using auxiliary hypotheses. In Logik der Forschung, he introduced the notion of "(degrees of) content". He proposed that only modifications that increase the empirical content of a theory should be considered.

In a series of articles beginning in 1979, Adolf Grünbaum argued, with examples, that Freudian psychoanalytic theories are in fact falsifiable. He criticized Popper's analysis of Freud's psychoanalytic theories and, on this basis, questioned the applicability of the demarcation criterion in general.

Falsifiability, probability statement and metaphysics

Popper identified scientific statements with falsifiable statements and distinguished them from metaphysical statements. However, he considered metaphysical statements useful in science. In particular, probabilistic statements are non falsifiable and thus metaphysical in Popper's terminology. There are many other kinds of metaphysical statements that are useful in Popper's view. For examples, "all men are mortal" is metaphysical, because it is not falsifiable, but such statements suggest other hypotheses that are more precise and more useful, for example "all men die before reaching the age of 150". Similarly, probabilistic hypotheses suggest other hypotheses that are falsifiable such as the acceptance criteria for the null hypothesis in a statistical test. As another example: a statistical hypothesis like a chi-square test is not a universal statement; it concerns a specific study, but is falsifiable and thus useful in critical discussions. A probability statement like "the probability of both heads and tails are 1/2" is not falsifiable; Popper called this problem of strengthening probability statements to make them falsifiable (i.e. incompatible with some sequences) and thus not metaphysical "the problem of decidability of probability statements".

Critical thinking, not support

Popper distinguished between trusting a theory because it is true and preferring a theory because it has been more severely tested. Some have argued that, indirectly, Popper was adopting an inductive principle when he proposed to "prefer" a more severely tested theory. For Popper, the term "induction" refers to a logical method of justification, and he emphasized that this preference does not result from such a logical process whose premises would be the results of rigorous tests. For Popper, results of rigorous tests are rather used in critical discussions. He wrote:

[T]here is no "absolute reliance"; but since we have to choose, it will be "rational" to choose the best-tested theory. This will be "rational" in the most obvious sense of the word known to me: the best-tested theory is the one which, in the light of our critical discussion, appears to be the best so far, and I do not know of anything more "rational" than a well-conducted critical discussion.

— Karl Popper, Logik der Forschung (1934)

Moreover, critical discussions must consider how much the theory prohibits and thus is unlikely to survive the tests, as well as whether the theory supersedes previous theories by generalizing them as when speaking of all heavenly bodies instead of only planets. Popper regularly emphasized that criticism in critical discussions requires the use of background knowledge, but rejected the view there will always be a set of assumptions beyond rational assessment. In particular, Popper brought this point in the context of the empirical basis of science, which he compared to a swamp into which it is always possible to drive pillars deeper if a more solid foundation is needed.

The critical rationalism approach to evaluating scientific theories can be generalized to non-scientific domains. Critical rationalists hold that any claims to knowledge can and should be rationally criticized, and, if they have empirical content, can and should be subjected to tests which may falsify them. They are either falsifiable and thus empirical (in a very broad sense), or not falsifiable and thus non-empirical. The general principle of critical rationalism is the same in both cases: we critically analyze the hypotheses using our "background knowledge". In the case of scientific hypotheses, background knowledge is used while observation statements are discussed or analysed.

Justified true belief versus objective knowledge

In mainstream epistemology, there are different types of knowledge, such as knowing someone or knowing how to drive, each associated with a type of mental and biological phenomenon. Knowledge defined as justified true belief is also a particular type of mental phenomenon. In this case, at the very least, the phenomenon is a belief in a fact identified by a proposition. The proposition in question must also be true, because it is absurd to say that we possess knowledge of something false. The proposition must also be justified.

Defining knowledge as a justified true belief is rarely a foundation accepted without discussion. On the contrary, it often constitutes a starting point for critical analysis based on counterexamples such as those presented by Gettier. For example, Meinong, at the beginning of the 20th century, cites the example of a man disturbed by ringing in his ears coming from his head. He infers that someone is ringing his doorbell when, by chance, someone is. His belief is true and justified by sensory perception, but, in a critical analysis of knowledge, he was simply lucky and doesn't really know that someone is ringing his doorbell. Long before this, similar counterexamples were raised in the Indian tradition and in ancient Greece.

These historical examples suggest that this view of knowledge has always been studied and criticized throughout the long history of philosophy. However, it was only in the mid-20th century that the analysis of knowledge as a justified mental attitude toward a true proposition emerged as a major subject of study in epistemology. According to Sander Verhaegh, prior to this period, Russell, Moore, and others had briefly analyzed knowledge as a justified true belief, but only to reject this project.

In contrast to this emphasis on justifying beliefs, Popper advanced the method of conjectures and refutations, in which beliefs can play a role in choosing a hypothesis or conjecture, but do not interfere with the use of deductive logic to test theories. Popper did not reject the role of beliefs and other subjective aspects in the development of knowledge, but in his methodology, the logical component is deductive and applies directly to conjectures and observational statements, free from psychologism.

This did not prevent authors such as Bredo Johnsen and Paul Tibbetts from criticizing Popper as if he had claimed that logic and methodology were sufficient to explain the development of knowledge. Johnsen points out that Popper explains that the method of error elimination using logical refutations requires that a finite number of theories be studied. He argues that Popper does not explain how one arrives at this finite number of theories. Tibbetts raises the question of "whether Popper’s position can take into account creative insight, discovery, and serendipity in science for these would clearly qualify as subjective phenomena [in Popper's position]".

On this subject, Popper admitted that objective knowledge develops through the individual contributions of researchers and that this depends on their biological predisposition to produce new, working theories: for Popper, “objectivity depended not on neutralizing the scientist’s subjective dispositions – which was, in any case, impossible – but on subjecting all theories to severe testing”. Popper accepted Hume’s conclusion that it is futile to attempt to provide a method to guide or validate the process of discovery. He used the terms “expectations” and “dispositions” to explain the development of knowledge and our mental capacities.

According to Suzan Haack, to support his approach, Popper has to make a problematic distinction between logic and empirical theories.

For her part, Susan Haack criticizes the separation that Popper seems to make between the rules of logic and the mathematical statements forming the empirical laws or axioms of its structures. Regarding the autonomy that Popper attributes to the world of objective knowledge, she writes:

Is not the point just this: that just as the nests, etc., that animals create are subject to natural laws which are not of the animals' creation, so the theories, etc., that we create are subject to logical laws which are not of our making? If this is the point, I think it needs to be said that it is more surprising than it perhaps looks. For it requires Popper to draw a sharp line between empirical science and mathematics, which he explicitly says that we have created, and logic, which, on this interpretation, he must hold to be entirely independent of us.

— Susan Haack, Epistemology with a Knowing Subject, 1979

On this subject, Popper defended an evolutionary view of the whole of human capacities, including our ability to use language and logic in its function of argumentation, but he also specified that this biological aspect did not fall within the field of epistemology.

He accepted that the choice of methodological rules must take into account subjective, moral, or biological aspects such as the limits of human mental capacities, but he compared the rules of scientific methodology to the rules of chess, which can be understood without having to worry about any subjective aspects, apart from the capacity for rational thought and other similar functions. He gave examples that methodology can take into account regarding the activity of a scientist S in relation to a proposition p:

  • "S tries to understand p."
  • "S tries to think of alternatives to p."
  • "S tries to think of criticisms of p."
  • "S proposes an experimental test for p."
  • "S tries to axiomatize p."
  • "S tries to derive p from q."

He added that this is very different from the use of "S knows p" or "S believes p", or even "S wrongly believes p" or "S doubts p" in an analysis of knowledge and its justification.

For Popper, this separation between logic, methodology, and psychological aspects was the concrete reality in science; that is, his methodology, which is normative, is simultaneously descriptive of what he considered to be true scientific activity. He emphasized that a large part of science relies on standard deductive reasoning, even when it comes to comparison with observations. David Miller noted that, for Popper, knowledge is neither justified nor believed, and that, generally, scientific knowledge is not true (in any logical sense). Musgrave wrote that "Popper's theory of science, and his cure for relativism, rest upon his rejection of the traditional theory of knowledge as justified true belief."

Bayesianism vs conjecture and refutation

Use of probability in a verificationist approach, "similar in some ways to that of modern pragmatists and positivists", has been traced back to Carneades. In the first half of the 20th century, Reichenbach and Carnap argued that "the only criterion of theory-confirmation ought to be agreement with observed facts; the theory would thus be the 'most probable' one ... within a formal theory of inductive probability". Carnap studies have been related to Bayesianism. Theories are assigned a probability, outcomes also have a probability and, given an outcome, Bayes' theorem can be applied to revise the a priori probability of each theory. Bayes' theorem is useful when we have the background knowledge needed to establish the a priori probability of characteristic parameters of the application domain and the probability of the observed data depends on these parameters: the parameters that fit the data and therefore the domain get revised with a higher probability.

Andrew Gelman en 2012
Cosma Shalizi
For Gelman (top) and Shalizi (bottom), the application of Bayes' theorem uses the hypothetico-deductive approach to revise models.

This view on the growth of knowledge has been criticized. Andrew Gelman and Cosma Shalizi, for example, wrote that the use of Bayes's theorem in practice is closer to the hypothetico-deductive approach, as proposed by Popper and others, than to the approach according to which the revision of probabilities is the sole consequence of the observed data. In their work, they examine the actual role played by prior distributions in Bayesian models, and the crucial aspects of model checking and model revision, which fall outside the scope of Bayesian confirmation theory.

Critical rationalism is against the use of probability to assess theories. Popper explained that the greater the informative content of a theory the lower will be its probability. The methodological rule is to aim for a bold theory that is likely to be false. He wrote that in "many cases, the more improbable (improbable in the sense of the calculus of probability) hypothesis is preferable".

Popper's break with positivism

The significance of Popper's opposition to logical positivism is disputed. The logical positivists associated empirical meaning with verification or confirmation by experience. Popper instead presented falsifiability as a criterion of empirical scientific status rather than of meaningfulness, accepted that metaphysical statements could be meaningful, and denied that successful predictions establish a theory as true or probable. Corroboration reported how a theory had performed under severe tests; it was not inductive support for believing the theory true or probable.

Historian and philosopher of physics John D. Norton considers that Popper's rejection of confirmation is a "minor" variation of the logical positivists' position.

Some philosophers consider this rejection of confirmation untenable or insufficient to distinguish Popper fundamentally from the positivists. For example, in a teaching context, John D. Norton considers Popper’s rejection of inductivist confirmation in favor of his criterion of refutability to be a “minor variation” of the logical positivists’ position, and describes the differences between the two conceptions as insignificant. In presenting his theory of material induction, Norton acknowledges that Popper "vigorously insisted" that corroboration is not confirmation; however, Norton aligns himself with the tradition holding that Popper's conception can only be reconciled with scientific practice if corroboration provides a "license for belief", a license that must be all the more solid the more robust the corroboration is.

Unlike Norton, Alain Boyer  presents Popper’s break with positivism as fundamental. According to Boyer, Popper retains the empiricist requirement that scientific theories be tested against experience, but denies that successful predictions provide inductive justification for their truth or probability. This rejection of an ultimate foundation for knowledge does not mean that experience makes no positive contribution to learning or discovery. On the contrary, Boyer emphasizes that, for Popper, human beings are “seekers of regularities” who generalize and reason by analogy on the basis of fallible expectations, whether innate or acquired; the critical requirement is that the resulting generalizations be subjected to empirical testing. Boyer also contrasts the Vienna Circle's project of eliminating metaphysics through a unified scientific language with Popper's view that metaphysical questions and hypotheses may remain rationally discussable and scientifically useful.

Local induction: material induction and inductive machine

Norton discussed the Popperian rejection of confirmation in the context of his theory of material induction. Popper accepted that, when the appropriate objective conditions obtain, an inductive machine could learn from experience by discovering regularities and by formulating, testing, and eliminating hypotheses. He added that human beings, too, could successfully employ such procedures. He nevertheless denied that the machine could establish that its own objective conditions of application were fulfilled. The machine’s designers could do so, but they first had to determine what constituted the machine’s world, its events, properties, repetitions, and the kinds of questions it was to answer. According to Popper, “all the more important and difficult questions” had thus already been solved when the machine and its world were constructed. The procedure could therefore contribute positively to the discovery of local laws without providing grounds for believing them true or probable, or for believing that the presuppositions making its application possible were actually satisfied.

Boyer, following Popper, sees human beings as seekers of regularities whose projections beyond the data are structured by fallible expectations, whether innate or acquired. He interprets ordinary inductions as context-dependent generalizations that presuppose a local hypothesis concerning the representativeness of the observed sample. According to Boyer, the inductive risk belongs to this local representativeness hypothesis rather than to a universal principle of induction; experience cannot establish its own representativeness.

Norton's material theory makes inductive inferences dependent on contingent, domain-specific facts, but assigns those facts a confirmatory role: his “material postulates” justify inductions and can make them truth-conducive. Secondary accounts characterize Norton's proposal as claiming that material facts both enable and justify inductive inference. Schurz argues that attempts to justify these domain-specific generalizations inductively lead to circularity or an infinite regress.

Gelman and Shalizi describe statistical models as tools for drawing inductive inferences against a “deductive background.” They add that these inferences are deductively guaranteed by the models’ probabilistic assumptions and that their application depends on contingent material facts specific to the system under study, “exactly as Norton argues.” Brandon G. Nielsen and Daniel C. Elton, for their part, argue that any successful application of Bayesian updating must be embedded within a broader evolutionary process. According to them, constructing a useful Bayesian model itself requires a Popperian process of trial and error elimination.

Variations

Mario Bunge's scientific realism draws on Popper's critical rationalism.

William Warren Bartley developed a variation of critical rationalism that he called pancritical rationalism.

The Argentine-Canadian philosopher of science Mario Bunge criticized Popper's critical rationalism, while drawing on it to formulate an account of scientific realism.

Personalized medicine

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personalized_medicine Personalize...